Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. SIDDIES ON THE ECOLOO.Y OF LYlmAEA TOMEN.rOSA PFEIFPER. 1 855 AND ?. COLUMELLA SAY 1 81 7 (MOLWSCA : GAS'IROPODA) , INTER.MEDIATE HOSTS OF THE COMMON LIVER. FLUKE FASCIOLA HEPATICA LINNAEUS 1 758 IN NEW ZEALAND A thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosopny in Veterinar,y Science at Massey Universi? ROBERT ERIC HARRIS December 1 974. .. l 1 1 ABSTRACT Studies on the ecology of Lymnaea tomentosa and ?. columella were carried out to provide a basis for further studies on the ecology of Fasciola hepatica infections in New Zealand. Intermediate hosts of !? hepatica in New Zealand are the native Australasian species ?. tomentosa, an introduced American snail 1,. columella, and the European host ?. trungatula. The literature on the systematics, geographical distribution, general biology and ecology of these snails, together with their relationships with!? hepatica, is reviewed. Field observations on snail habitats indicated that ?. columella occupied ponds and spring fed marshes which remained wet even in dr,y seasons. ?. tomentosa was found in ?imilar marsh habitats. Stability appeared to be an important quality of the habitats of both species; factors unfavourable to the snails included rapid? flowing water, i marked seasonal fluctuations in water level, and shade from tall vegetation. The calcium content of water in habitats ranged from 4 to 70 ppm. Snails were more often found on flocculent than on firm mud and this preference was more marked in the case of ?. tomentosa. Snail population dynamics were examined on one pond habitat and three marsh habitats of ?. columella and a marsh habitat of ?. tomentosa. Age structure and densit.y of populations fluctuated wide? between and within each of the five years of the study. These changes were greater in populations of ?. columella and not directly related to rainfall or temperature variations. Field and laboratory evidence showed that both species could breed throughout the year even when temperatures were as low as 5?C but populations were much larger in summer and ear? autumn. Studies of the fecundity of the two snail species and the relationship between temperature and rate of development of eggs showed that whilst ?. columella has a higher adult mortality rate it also has a much greater reproductive potential than ?. tomentosa. Eggs of 1,. columella develop over a wider range of temperatures, hatching up to 0 0 34.5 C whereas temperatures above 30 C are lethal to eggs of ?. tomentosa. Eggs of both species underwent some development at temperatures between 5 and 1 0 ? C but the proportion that hatched at low temperatures was very small, particularly in the case of !!,. tomentosa. Both species showed similar responses to desiccation on filter paper at 16.5?C and 80 to 9oft relative humidity; survival time was closely related to shell length, with large snails considerably more resistant than smaller specimens. When snails were subjected to desiccation on mud results were much less predictable and the mean shell length of survivors was often less than that of snails which died. A biometric analysis of shell shape showed distinct differences between large specimens of ?. tomentosa and ?. columella but shell dimension ratios were not diagnostic in specimens under 4 mm in length. Examination of a pond and a marsh population of ?. columella showed no differences in shell shape attributable to habitats. Over a 5 year period there was no detectable relationship between the intensity of !? hepatica transmission from a ?. columella habitat and snail population density. The on? correlation between !? hepatica transmission and rainfall was a possible inverse relationship between uptake in tracer sheep and December/January (mid-summer) rainfall. There was no evidence of any overwintering infection of ?. hepatica infection in ?. columella. Uptake of flukes by tracer sheep was almost totally confined to the period between mid-summer and mid-winter. Both experimental and circumstantial evidence indicated that pugging by cattle rendered marsh habitats more suitable for snails, although exclusion of cattle from the experimental area coincided with an increase in the uptake of !? hepatica by tracer sheep. ii PREFACE Fasciola hepatica Linnaeus 1758, the common liver fluke, is a common parasite of grazing animals in IllB.l'\Y parts of the world; its wide range of mammalian hosts includes man. It is of considerable economic importance due to its own pathogenicity and as a precursor of "black disease" in association with the bacterium Clostridium nowi. iii The liver fluke is also of great biological and pedagogic interest as a model of a parasite vdth a succession of free-living and parasitic stages, as testified by the space devoted to descriptions of its life-cycle in textbooks of zoology and parasitology. There has been a recent revival of interest in fascioliasis in New Zealand due to an increase in the prevalence and distribution of the disease. The aim of the present study of the ecology of two of the intermediate hosts of ?:. hepatica, Lymnaea tomentosa Pfeiffer 18SS and 1,. columella S?zy 1817, is to provide some basis for fUrther studies on the ecology, epidemiology and control of fascioliasis in New Zealand. Whenever possible the information obtained in this study was quantified and analysed statistically. The maximum level of probability that a result could have arisen by chance regarded as "statistically significant" is .os. The use of one, two or three asterisks a:f'ter the result of an analysis implies a probability of less than .OS, .? and .? respectively, and is equivalent to the terms p"'-.OS, pL.? and p?.001. .ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Many people helped both directly and indirectly in the production of this thesis. Among the latter, who will not receive individual mention, were those friends whose casual enquiries acted as a stimulus to greater effort. More direct assistance was given by the following people : ? supervisors, Dr. W.A.G. Charleston of the Veterinar,y Faculty of this university and Dr. L.K. Whitten from the Veterinary Research Division of the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries were unfailingly patient and help:ful. Dr. Charleston, being on hand, bore the greater burden but Dr. Whitten gave much useful advice, usually at short notice and often at inconvenient times. Professor R.N. Munford of the Veterinary Faculty, Mr. G.C. Arnold of the Mathematics Department, and Mr. c.s. Clarke of the Department of Food Technology all assisted with advice on statistical analyses but since they did not act as proof readers aey remaining errors are II\Y own. I had some stimulating discussions with Mr. N.B. Pullan in the early stages of the study, often during the course of a visit to a snail habitat one of us thought would be of interest to the other. Dr. M.J. Winterbourn of the Zoology Department, Canterbury University, identified the Ph.ysa found on the Pohangina farm? Others to whom nty thanks are due include Mr. D .K. Signal, Pohangina, and Mr. J. M. R,yder, Tokomaru, the farmers on whose property the snail population studies were conducted; both were totally co-operative at all times. The same is true of the management and staff of the c.w.s. Ltd. Meat Export Works, Longburn and the veterinary and lay staff of the Meat Division of the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries. Other Massey University staff whose help was invaluable were Mr. T.G. Law of the central photographic unit, the university printer Mr. P.J. Herbert, Mrs. L.C. Battye of the library, and the sheep farm supervisor Mr. P.H. Whitehead. I also acknowledge gratefully the grant from the Veterinary Faculty research fund which paid for sheep, fencing materials and other equipment. I am especially grateful to a most efficient and enthusiastic typist, Mrs. Joy Pearce. Almost none of the problems alleged to be inevitable in producing type drafts of PhD theses arose, and most of the minor errors discovered in the final draft were due to nty inadequate editing at an earlier stage. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT i PREFACE iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iv 1 ? INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE SURVEY 1 1 .1 Systematics of the New Zealand Lymnaeidae 1 1 .1 .1 Some morphological features of the New Zealand Lymnaeidae 2 1 .2 Geographical distribution of the snail hosts of Fasciola hepatica 5 1 ? 2.1 Lymnaea truncatula 1 .2.2 Lymnaea tomentosa 1 .2.3 Lymnaea columella 1 .2.4 Other snail hosts 1 .3 General biology of the snail hosts of Fasciola hepatic a 1 .3 .1 Growth 1 .3.2 Circulate? system 1 .3.3 Respiration 1 .3.4 Feeding and digestion 1 .3.5 Reproduction 5 7 7 8 8 8 10 10 11 12 1 .4 Ecology of the snail hosts of Fasciola hepatica 14 1 .4.1 Habitats 14 1 .4.2 Food 18 1 .4.3 Effects of temperature 19 1 .4.4 Aestivation 21 1.4.5 Light 22 1 .4.6 Behaviour 1 .4 .7 Intra-specific relationships 1 .4.8 Inter-specific relationships 1 .4.9 Life cycles in the field 23 23 25 28 V 2. Page 1 .5 The relationship between Fasciola hepatica and its snail hosts 29 29 31 1 .5.1 Miracidia and snails 1 .5.2 The intra-molluscan stages 1.6 The epidemiology of Fasciola hepatica 1 .6 .1 Prevalence 33 33 1 .6 .2 The epidemiology of Fasciola hepatica infections transmitted by Lymnaea truncatula 34 1 .6 .3 The epidemiology of Fasciola hepatica infections transmitted by Lymnaea tomentosa 35 1 .6.4 The epidemiology of Fasciola hepatica infections transmitted by Lymnaea columella 37 HABITATS 38 38 38 44 44 48 48 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Terminology Macrohabi tats Microhabitats 2.3 .1 Sampling methods 2.3.2 Analytical method 2.3.3 Results Discussion Conclusions 51 55 3. POPULATION STUDIES 3.1 Habitats 57 57 62 62 67 3 .2 Methods 3 .2.1 Sampling 3.2.2 Temperature and rainfall 3 .3 Results 3.3.1 3.3 .2 3 .3 .3 3 .3 .4 Population densi? Shell lengths and population structure The effects of pugging Temperature and rainfall 3 .4 Discussion 3.4.1 3 .4.2 3.4 .3 Sampling methods Snail populations The effects of cattle upon marsh habitats 67 67 69 74 77 84. 84. 85 87 vi Page 4. THE EPIDEMIOLOGY OF FASCIOLA HEPATICA INFECTIONS m SHEEP GRAZING A MARSH HABITAT OF LYMNAEA COLUMELLA 89 89 90 91 96 5 . 6. 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Methods 4.3 Results 4.4 Discussion REARING SNAILS m THE LABORATORY 101 5.1 Introduction 101 5.2 Experiments 101 5 .3 Summary of results 119 5.4 Discussion 120 OVIPOSITION 123 123 123 125 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 Introduction Methods Results 6.3.1 6.3.2 6.3.3 6.3.4 6.3.5 6.3.6 6.3. 7 6.3.8 Comparative fecundity of ?? tomentosa and ?. columella Shell length and :fecundity Growth rate and fecundity Eggs per capsule and the stage of oviposition The effect of water changes upon fecundity The relationship between capsule production and egg production Oviposition at low temperatures Summary of results 125 127 132 132 137 140 142 142 Discussion 142 6.4.1 Relative fecundity of L. tomentosa and f!. columella - 142 6.4.2 Shell length and :fecundity 143 6.4.3 Factors influencing the number of eggs per capsule 145 6.4.4 Water changes and :fecundity 147 6.4.5 The relationship between capsule production and egg production 1 47 6.4.6 The significance of oviposition at low temperatures 1 48 vii 7. 8. 9. THE EFFECTS OF TEMPER.A'IURE .AND DESICCATION UPON THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE EGGS OF LYMNAEA TOMENTOSA AND J!. COLUMELLA AND OBSERVATIONS ON THE RESPONSE OF THE SNAILS TO HEAT STRESS 7.1 7.2 7.3 Introduction Experiments 7.2 .1 7 .2.2 7.2.3 7.2.4 7.2.5 Comparison of the oviposition to hatching time o f' eggs from different snails of the same species The ef'f'ect of temperature upon the rate of' development from oviposition to hatching Viabilit,y of' the eggs of'?. tomentosa and J!. columella af'ter holding at 4oc The relative susceptibility of' the L. tomentosa and L. columella to desiccation - The resistance of' J!. tomentosa and .!!- columella to heat stress eggs of Discussion THE EFFECTS UPON LYMNAEA TOMENTOSA AND L. COLUMELLA OF DESICCATION IN AIR - 8.1 Introduction 8.2 Method 8.3 Results 8.4 Discussion DESICCATION ON MUD 9.1 Introduction 9.2 Methods 9.3 Results 9.4 Discussion Page 149 149 149 149 150 153 158 159 160 164 164 164 166 170 174 174 174 179 188 1 0. SHELL SHAPE 191 1 0.1 Introduction 10.2 Methods 10.3 Results 191 191 194 1 0.3 .1 Comparison of' li,. tomentosa and &. polumella 1 94 ? viii 10.3 .2 Changes in shell shape associated with size 10.3 .3 Changes in the shell shape of ?. columella associated with habitats and collection Page 195 dates 198 10.4 Discussion 202 11 ? GENERAL DISCUSSION 204. REFERENCES 209 APPENDICES 221 ix Table 1 .1 2.1 2.2 3.1 3 .2a 3 .2b 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 4.1 4.2 5.1 5.2 LIST OF TABLES Reported oviposition to hatching times for the eggs of &? truncatula and k_. tomentosa Chemical values of water from some selected habitats of &. tomentosa and k.? columella Associations between Lymnaea tomentosa or Lymnaea columella and some habitat factors Habitats whose Lymnaea populations were studied Numbers of positive samples (one or more snails) in pugged and control quadrats from habitats no. 2 and 3 Numbers of Lymnaeid snails collected from habitats 2 and 3, pugged and control quadrats Monthly rainfall (mm) Pohangina Domain Monthly rainfall (mm) Tiritea Mean monthly temperatures (?C) recorded at D.S .I.R., Palmerston North Annual rainfall and Lymnaea population density Percentages of k.? columella 9 mm in shell length in pooled annual collections from the marsh habitat, and the uptake of flukes in tracer sheep Deviations from a 21 year mean rainfall (mm) in Pohangina Domain Summary of results of experiment 5.2 Effects of :food and water upon mean growth rates of k.? columella during experiment 5.2 X Page 20 43 49 62 78 79 80 81 82 83 95 95 106 107 Table 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5 .8 5 .9 5 .10 5.11 5.12 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 Deaths of both species in experiments 5.2 and 5.3 Mean increases in she 11 length during experiments 5.3 ani 5.5 Effects of food and water upon mean growt.l-J. rates of ?. columella during experiment 5.3 Effects of food and water upon mean growth rates of ?. tomentosa during experiment 5.3 Deaths of & . tomentosa dltt'ing experiment 5.4 The effects of meat and vegetable supplements on the production of egg capsules by &. tomentosa in experiment 5.4 The effects of meat and vegetable supplements on the number of young snails produced by L. tomentosa in experiment 5.4 - Survival times of immature L. tomentosa and ?. columella in experiment 5.5 - ?rowth rates of L. columella and &? tomentosa in experiment 5.5- Second generation snails at the end of experiment 5.5 Fecundity of mature snails under different experimental conditions Comparison of fecundity of three size groups of snails from experiment 6.1 (?. tomentosa ) Analysis of variance of differences in egg production between the three size groups of Table 6.2 (?. tomentosa ) Differences in eggs per capsule between the three size groups of ?. tomentosa in experiment 6.1 Two level nested ana?sis of variance of results shown in Table 6.4 Regression of egg production for the f'irst period of experiment 6 .1 on shell length of ?. tomentosa Regression of capsule production on the increase in shell length of &? columella during experiment 6.3 xi Page 108 109 110 111 113 114 11 5 117 118 119 126 127 128 128 129 129 132 Table 6.8 6.9 6.10 6.11 6.12 6.13 6.14 6.15 6.16 6.17 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 Regression o:f eggs per capsule on increase in shell length o:f ?. columella during experiment 6.3 Di:f:ferenoes in eggs per capsule produced by ?? tomentosa during the :first period at 24?C in experinent 6.1 comparing (a) smils which died with (b) snails which survived Di:f:ferences in eggs per capsule produced by ?. tomentosa during the second period at 24?C comparing (a) snails that stopped la.ying with (b) snails th at produced eggs throughout the experiment The ef:fect o:f water changes upon :fecundity of ?. tonentosa in experiment 6.1 The effect o:f water changes upon fecundity of ?. columella in experiment 6.3 Analysis of variance of capsule production by 1? columella in experiment 6.3 to test the effect of water changes Analysis of variance of egg production by ?. columella in experiment 6.3 to test the effect of water changes Correlations between total capsule production by groups o:f snails and their total egg production at each collection date Examples o:f some correlations between total capsule production and egg production by individual snails Mean eggs per capsule produced by ?. columella (Data from Baily, 1931) Comparison of the oviposition to hatching time of egg capsules from twenty-one ?. columella at 20?C Means and stardard deviations of oviposition to hatching times for ?. columella as assessed by (a) hatching of the first egg in each capsule, and (b) hatching of 5<$ of the eggs in each capsule Stepwise IID.lltiple regression of days to hatching of egg capsules on temperaillre Viabilit.y of the eggs of ?. tomentosa and ?. columella after storage at 4?C xii Page 132 136 137 138 139 139 139 141 141 146 150 1 51 1 P3 156 Table 7.5 7.6 7.7 8.1 8.2 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 9.9 9.10 Statistical evaluation of some of the results shown in Table 7.3 Resistance of egg capsules to desiccation The relationship between the log of days to hatching and temperatures above 25?C for egg capsules of ?. tomentosa and ?? columella Relationships between shell length and LD50 in 1? columella and 1? tomentosa Comparison of the regression lines for log LD50 on log shell length in ?. columella and ?. tomentosa by analysis of covariance Survival rates of snails recovere d at the end of experiman t 9 .1 Survival rates of snails recovered at the end of experimant 9. 2 Survival rates of snails recovered at the eoo of experiment 9.3 Survival rates of snails recovered at the end of experiment 9.2 with regard to location of the snails Survival of 1? columella with regard to its location at the end of e::1