Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. Discovery, a Case Study on the New Zealand Lifeskills and Study Skills Programme for Adolescents, and its Contribution to Adolescent Development A thesis presented in partial .fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Education at Massey University, Palmerston North Catherine Ellen McGachie 2000 11 ABSTRACT This case study examined Discovery, a lifeskills and study skills programme for adolescents, and it's contribution to adolescent development. The Discovery programme was introduced in New Zealand in 1991 through the Global Youth Foundation. Developmental perspectives in adolescence suggest certain tasks and skills need to be achieved in order to reach adulthood. These skills are developed from the maturational demands, and the psychological and social adjustments the teenager needs to make in order to resolve their identity crisis (Erikson, 1968) and achieve their own identity. A review of international educational programmes suggested some of these needs were addressed. A case study on the Discovery programme probed into the programme's development, content and structure. Responses to Discovery from previous participants were also investigated. This study then focused on the 22nd Discovery programme in New Zealand and its contribution to teenage development. This involved an exploration into Discovery's contribution to lifeskills, study skills, coping with challenges and limiting or preventing depression in the adolescent years. The Lifeskills and Study Skills questionnaire (LASS) was developed to examine these aspects. Parent-Adolescent communication was also measured to understand what changes may have taken place between two weeks prior to Discovery and two months after the last day of the programme. The Parent-Adolescent Communication Scale by Barnes and Olson (1982) was used to determine this. The resulting trends in this research showed Discovery positively influenced the participants' development by providing a number of skills which were consistent with developmental perspectives of adolescence. Sections of Discovery were highlighted as important for an adolescent's growth and development and participant changes were since attributed to Discovery. This study showed that Parent-Adolescent communication 111 improved for both the majority of teenagers and their parents. Intrafamily communication also enhanced for more than half the families. Sections of Discovery could also be highlighted as beneficial for coping with challenges and the prevention or limitation of depression in the adolescent years. Overall, Discovery provided the skills and knowledge appropriate for the development of an adolescent. The seven day programme provided the forum for an initiation into adulthood similar to many "rites of passage" formalities. This study highlighted the skills required for adolescents in the New Zealand context and the confirmation of the developmental tasks outlined in Newman and Newman's (1995) "early adolescence". Recommendations from this research strongly supports the need for further research into educational programmes for teenagers. It is also recommended that the Discovery programme continues to be made available to New Zealand teenagers. iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank the teens, parents and adults who participated in this study. Their enthusiasm in completing the questionnaires and interviews was most appreciated. This research could not have taken place without the co-operation and support of the Global Youth Foundation. For this, I am truly grateful to the members of the Board of Trustees and those in the National Office who helped me throughout the data gathering process. Thanks also to my Supervisor Dr. Wilhelmina Drummond for her advice and encouragement throughout the project. Finally, much appreciation and gratitude to my husband, family and friends who supported and encouraged me along the way. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TITLE PAGE ABSTRACT ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iv TABLE OF CONTENTS v LIST OF FIGURES ix LIST OF TABLES x PART ONE 1 CHAPTER ONE - INTRODUCTION 2 Background 2 Overview of the Developmental Perspective 3 The Rationale of the Research 4 The Aims of the Research 5 Definitions of Terms 6 Limitations and Delimitations of the Study 10 Summary 11 CHAPTER TWO - REVJEW OF LITERATURE AND DEVELOPMENTAL PERSPECTIVES 14 Lifeskills Training Programmes for Adolescents 14 An Overview of Programmes Available for New Zealand Teenagers 15 A Review of Life skills Training Programmes - International 16 Study Skills 21 Challenges in Adolescence and Adolescent Coping Ability 23 Depression in Adolescence 26 Parent-Adolescent Communication 29 Developmental Perspectives of Adolescence 31 Cognitive Learning and the Social Environment 38 Societal Changes Influencing Adolescence 40 The Period of Adolescence and the ''Rites of Passage" 42 Conclusion 43 CHAPTER THREE - DESCRIPTION OF THE METHOD OF THIS CASE STUDY 46 Rationale for the Research Design 46 Framework ofthis Chapter 47 The Aims and Research Questions 48 The Methodology Relating to the First Aim 50 The Methodology Relating to the Second Aim 53 The Methodology Relating to the Third Aim 54 The Lifeskills and Study Skills Questionnaire ~ASS) 56 - Pilot Testing of the LASS Questionnaire 57 - Method of Gathering Data Using the LASS Questionnaire 58 - Analysis Procedure of the LASS Questionnaire 59 The Parent-Adolescent Commuoication Scale (PACS) 59 - Method of Gathering Data Using the PACS 61 - The P ACS Sampling Procedure 63 - Pilot Tes.ting of the PACS Covering Letter 64 - Scoring P ACS 65 - Analysis Procedure of the P ACS Questionnaire 65 Discovery NZ22 Participants 66 Ethical Considerations 67 Summary 68 PART TWO 69 CHAPTERFOUR-THEDEVELOPMENT,CONTENTANDSTRUCTURE OF THE DISCOVERY PROGRAMME FOR NEW ZEALAND ADOLESCENTS: THE RESULTS 70 Framework of This Chapter 70 The Development of Discovery (in answer to Research Question 1-1) 70 Discovery, it's Purpose and Intended Outcomes (in answer to Research Question 1-2) 72 Discovery's Participants (in answer to Research Question 1-3) 74 Scheduling and Venue of the Discovery Programme (in answer to Research Question 1-4) 75 Mode of Address (in answer to Research Question 1-5) 75 The Structure and Training of Staff (in answer to Research Question 1-6) 76 The Content of Discovery (in answer to Research Question 1-7) 79 An Explanation of Sections of Discovery 79 The Content of the Discovery Programme for Teenagers 89 - Teen Workshop 89 - Parents l 00 - Both Parents and Teens Together 100 - StaffWorkshop 102 Summary 102 CHAPTER FIVE - PREVIOUS PARTICIPANTS' VIEWS OF DISCOVERY: THE RESULTS, ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS 104 Introduction 104 The Results: Previous Participants' Views of Discovery 105 The Analysis and Conclusions: Previous Participants' Views of Discovery and the Contribution to Their Development 112 Discussion 114 CHAPTER SIX - PARTICIPANTS' PERCEPTIONS OF DISCOVERY NZ22: THE RESULTS, ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS 115 Introduction 115 The Structure of This Chapter 116 VI The Results: The Lifeskills and Study Skills Sections of Discovery NZ22 (in answer to Research Question 3-1) 116 The Participants' Views on Discovery NZ22' s Lifeskills Sections 116 - The Most Useful Lifeskills Sections of Discovery 116 - The Least Useful Lifeskills Sections of Discovery 118 - Other Comments or Suggestions Given About the Lifeskills Sections of Discovery 120 The Analysis and Conclusions: Discovery's Lifeskills Sections and Their Contribution to Teenage Development 121 The Participants' Views on Discovery NZ22' s Study Skills Sections 127 - The Most Useful Study Skills Sections of Discovery 127 - The Least Useful Study Skills Sections of Discovery 128 - Other Comments or Suggestions Given About the Study Skills Sections of Discovery 131 The Analysis and Conclusions: Discovery's Study Skills Section and Their Contribution Teenagers Development 131 The Results: Changes in the Nature of Communication Between Parent and Teenager (in answer to Research Question 3-2) 134 The Changes in Parents' and Teenagers' Perception of Communication 135 The Number of Changes in Communication Scores 13 7 Communication Changes by Parent, Teen and Gender 13 8 Changes in Communication for First-Born Teen Families and Non First-Born Teen Families 140 The Analysis and Conclusions: The Changes in the Nature of Communication Between Parent and Teenager in Relation to the Literature 141 The Analysis and Conclusions· Discovery and its Influence on the Adolescent and Their Families 146 The Results: The Overall Perception of Discovery NZ22 in the Teenagers' Lives (in answer to Research Question 3-3) 147 The Overall Perception of Discovery's Influence in the Teenagers' Lives 148 The Analysis and Conclusions: The Overall Perception of Discovery's Influence in the Teenagers' Lives 150 The Results: The Contribution of the Sections of Discovery NZ22 on Coping Ability and Depression in the Adolescent Years: Participants' Viewpoint (in answer to Research Question 3-4) 152 Teenage Challenges and the Teenagers' View of Discovery's Contribution to Coping Ability in the Adolescent Years 15 3 Vll Teenage Depression and the Teenagers' View of Discovery's Contribution to Depression in the Adolescent Years 156 The Analysis and Conclusions: Depression and Coping Ability in Adolescence 159 The Analysis and Conclusions: Discovery's Influence in Preventing or Limiting Depression and the Ability to Cope With Challenges 162 Summary 166 CHAPTER SEVEN - DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 167 Discussion 167 Recommendations 170 REFERENCES 173 APPENDICES 190 I. Lifeskills and Study Skills Questionnaire (LASS) 190 II. Covering Letters for P ACS 1 & 2 196 III. Parent-Adolescent Communication Scale (PACS) 204 IV. Interview Consent Forms 206 V. Interview Format 208 Vlll Figure Number 6.1 6.2 6.3 LIST OF FIGURES New Study Skills Learnt Average Score Comparisons of Parent and Teen Communication Percentage of Participants who Showed an Increase in P ACS Scores Page Number 129 136 138 lX x LIST OF TABLES Table Page Number Number 3.1 Response Rate for Parent-Adolescent Communication Scale 63 5.1 Percentages of Teenagers who Rated the Sections as Favourite or Low Points 108 5.2 Percentage of Teenagers' Ratings of Discovery 109 5.3 Percentages of Teens from NZ20 and NZ21 who Made a Change in the Corresponding Questions 111 6.1 Sections From the Lifeskills Part of Discovery Found Useful by the Teenagers 117 6.2 Sections From the Lifeskills Part of Discovery Found Least Helpful by the Teenagers 118 6.3 Ratings of Study Skills by Percentages of Participants for Each Study Skill 127 6.4 Comparison of New and Improved Study Skills by Rank Order 130 6.5 Average Scores of PACS 1 and PACS 2 for Parents and Teens 137 6.6 Percentages of Gender/Role Participants who Showed a Change in Total Score 139 6.7 Difference (PACS 2 - PACS 1) in Average Total Score Within Each Group 141 6.8 Changes Noted in the Participants buring the Week 148 6.9 The Biggest Personal Breakthrough for the Teenagers 149 6.10 Sections of Discovery Which may Help Teenagers Cope with Challenges 155 6.11 Other Reasons Given for how Discovery Helps Teenagers Cope with Challenges 156 PART ONE CHAPTER ONE - INTRODUCTION CHAPTER TWO - REVIEW OF LITERATURE AND DEVELOPMENTAL PERSPECTIVES CHAPTER THREE - DESCRIPTION OF THE METHOD OF THIS CASE STUDY I 2 CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION This case study focused on the New Zealand. programme Discovery, a lifeskills and study skills programme for adolescents, and its contribution to adolescent development. The programme Discovery has been developed specifically for New Zealand adolescents aged between 13 to 18 years and has grown from the current Lead Facilitator's involvement with teenage programmes in Hawaii and Australia. The Discovery programme was introduced in New Zealand with the establishment of the Global Youth Foundation in 1991 . The Global Youth Foundation is a charitable trust devoted to offering programmes which promote the psychological and social well-being of the participants. Since Discovery was introduced to New Zealand, over 25 programmes have taken place, and continue to take place throughout the secondary school holidays. Discovery was designed to provide selected lifeskills and study skills training to fee-paying adolescents with a view to supporting their development during such an important transition in their life - from childhood to adulthood. Background The writer's prior involvement with the Discovery programme as an adult staff member, allowed her to informally observe changes in the teenage participants over the seven days of the teenage programme. The behavioural and attitudinal changes observed were dramatic for some of the young people. It was therefore the interest in understanding what, and how, Discovery, contributed to these observed changes that led to this research being undertaken. Although the Global Youth Foundation previously gathered information about Discovery through their own questionnaires, these questionnaires were not analysed and therefore no formal evaluation had been made as to how exactly the programme contributed to the lives of its participants. The search for the influence of 3 Discovery on the lives of the participants, particularly from a developmental perspective, and their responses to the evaluations of the programme, formed the basis of this research. To achieve this, an investigation into the Discovery programme itself was essential. The focus on skills training in adolescence is an important challenge because of its place in setting the building blocks for individuals to assume personal responsibility and the young people to find their place within society. The observed enhancement of the teenage participants' personal development prompted a group of parents to bring the Discovery programme from Australia to New Zealand. A group of parents who had experienced Discovery abroad, through their own involvement as staff, and the observed effects it had upon their own teenagers, set up the Global Youth Foundation to establish a foundation through which the Discovery programme could be facilitated in New Zealand. The Discovery programme, was designed to encourage each participant to respond effectively and joyfully to life's challenges and to its developmentally required tasks. The Global Youth Foundation promotes Discovery as a programme which provides the participants with the skills to learn, to communicate effectively and take responsibility for one's own well-being and one's direction in their lives. Through these skills, Discovery aims to increase self-esteem, self-confidence, positive attitudes to life and to encourage the family to work as a supportive co-operative unit (Discovery Core Staff Manual). Overview of the Developmental Perspectives The theoretical base contributing to this study stems from the developmental theory of Erik Erikson and his psychosocial perspective of adolescence. According to Erikson, adolescence is the fifth stage, out of eight stages in a person's life span development, called "identity versus role confusion". This period, covering the years from 10 to 21, is when the individual experiences an identity crisis, and the psychological crises and social 4 development skills interplay with the prospect of role confusion or diffusion (Erikson, 1963). The period of adolescence is the time in a person's life when they are faced with finding out who they are, what is important to them, and where they are going in life. A successful resolution of this crisis prepares them for the next crisis in early adulthood: Intimacy versus Isolation. James Marcia elaborated and expanded on Erikson's original bipolar stage identifying four identity statuses (identity confused/diffused, foreclosure, moratorium, identity achieved) based on a person's stage of commitment or non-commitment to a vocation (Kroger, 1989). In Jane Kroger's analysis of adolescent development she claims, "fidelity ot commitment to a vocation, a set of meaningful values, and a sexual identity are the observable cues indicative of a more or less successful identity resolution during late adolescence" (Kroger, 1989, p.34). In line with Erikson's psychosocial theory, Havighurst (1972) and Newman and Newman (1995) identified sets of developmental tasks - a set of skills and competencies that contribute to increased mastery over one's environment, that define what is healthy, normal development at each age in a particular society (Havighurst, 1972). Failure in achieving the tasks at one stage leads to greater difficulty in achieving later tasks which may even make succeeding tasks impossible to master (Newman & Newman, 1995). Each society has tasks and skills set for young people to learn in order to be admitted into adulthood and resolve the crisis at hand. The Discovery programme addresses a selection of developmental tasks which it attempts to cultivate in young people as they participate in the programme. The Rationale of the Study The role of the Discovery programme in enhancing the lifeskills and study skills of adolescents involved in the programme needed to be examined in light of the participants' view of its effectiveness in supporting their growth and development. It 5 was important to get some insight into participants' responses on what they got out of the programme and its influence on their development. With the introduction of the first Discovery programme in New Zealand in 1991, namely NZ 1, it was important to consider the tracing of its evolution and development, as well as focus on the organisational structure and the specific programme topics and activities of the 22nd Discovery programme held 12th to 18th July, 1998, at Nga Tawa School, Marton, New Zealand. With this knowledge, this study was intended to (1) identify the skills highlighted by the programme for adolescents, skills which were considered relevant to today's society and (2) study the participants' responses to Discovery's effectiveness in introducing selected lifeskills and study skills which support their development and their entry to adulthood. With this study of the Discovery programme in New Zealand, the rationale was to provide infonnation on it's role and contribution to the participants' development. In addition, it examined aspects of the programme which can be modified or improved so it could be more adaptable to the New Zealand environment. The Aims of the Research The aim of this research was to conduct a case study of the Discovery programme, by tracing its historical development, examining its programme content, organisational procedures, and its contribution to the teenage participants' development. More specifically, this research aimed: (i) To study the Discovery programme in New Zealand by examining its development, main purpose and aims, structure and content of the programme, availability of the programme, and the processes involved in staff training; (ii) To gain a background understanding of Discovery through an examination of previous participants' (Discovery NZ20 - 1997; NZ21 - 1998) responses to 6 the programme in relation to skills mastered as well as the participants' views of Discovery in relation to their achievements and their development. The researcher undertook this preliminary investigation as part of this study; and, (iii) To focus on a detailed study of Discovery NZ22 held 12th - 18th July 1998. In this section, the focus was on the participants' views regarding the contribution of Discovery to their lifeskills and study skills development, the nature of the communication patterns between the participating adolescents and parents, an overall perception of Discovery's influence in the teenage participants' lives, and, participants' views on challenging issues such as depression and coping and the aspects of Discovery which may have helped address these. Definition of Terms The terms "teenagers", "young people", "teens" and "adolescents" are used interchangeably in this thesis. For the purpose of this thesis, these terms refer to young people aged between 12-22 years. According to Newman and Newman (1995) there is a distinction between early adolescence and late adolescence. ''Early adolescence" refers to those aged between 12 and 18 years and "later adolescence" refers to young people aged between 19 and 22 years. Both these definitions are used within this thesis as it applies to Newman and Newman (1995). ''Developmental tasks" are described by Havighurst as a set of skills and competencies that contribute to increased mastery over one's environment, that define what is healthy, normal development at each age in a particular society (Havighurst, 1972). "A developmental task is a task which arises at or about a certain period in the life of the individual, successful achievement of which leads to his happiness and to success with later tasks, while failure leads to unhappiness in the individual, disapproval by the society, and difficulty with later tasks" (Havighurst, 1972, p. 2). Thus, a developmental task is halfway between and individual need and a societal demand. 7 The word ''lifeskills" refers a number of developmental tasks which, according to Nelson-Jones (1991), are chosen sequences in specific psychological and social contexts. These tasks are deemed necessary for the healthy development of an individual. Nelson-Jones (1991) describe lifeskills as having two levels. On one level lifeskills are the skills which enable a person to make personally responsible choices; they ensure a choice of behaviours. On another level they are motivational skills which enable people to help themselves; they aid in the chosen sequence of behaviours. According to Nelson-Jones (1991) lifeskills are aimed to empower rather than disempower people. "People require a repertoire of lifeskills according to their developmental tasks and specific problems ofliving" (Nelson-Jones, 1991, p.13). The specific types of lifeskills addressed in the Discovery NZ22 programme are skills relating to an individual successfully living in the social environment such as communication skills, forming meaningful and satisfying relationships, including parental, peer and boy/girl relationships, teamwork and acceptance of others. Other examples of lifeskills addressed at Discovery are focused around the strengthening of the internal structure or framework for living life as a responsible adult. Such skills covered include skills related to taking responsibility and control in one's life, being reliable and trustworthy, goal setting, coping strategies and the psychological adjustments required when faced with life's challenges, gaining confidence and motivation, and accepting oneself "Study skills" refers to strategies or tips for enhancing learning, particularly within the academic realm (Global Youth Foundation Promotional Brochure). The four specific study skills covered at Discovery are "mindmapping", "learning styles", "multiple intelligences", "memory techniques", and "speed reading', skills. Firstly, "mindmapping" refers to a technique where material to be learned is organised in a visual manner that is easily stored in long term memory. It is a most useful application of brain theory where the technique of mindmapping combines the skills associated with both the left and right 8 brain functioning such as logic, words, and symbols combined with left brain skills, and, the use of pattern, colour and shape for the right brain. The most common, versatile and easily learned rnindmap has branches corning out from a central title. This technique of displaying material pictorially and conceptually assists in easy learning. Secondly, "learning styles" refer to three most commonly expressions of how a person learns: visual, auditory and kinaesthetic. Those who have a visual learning preference would best learn by visual techniques, such as posters, reading or writing things down (Ward & Daley, 1993). Thus, visual communicators or learners tend to capture the concepts in their minds and/or use images. Auditory learners tend to listen and talk. They prefer to learn from lectures, talks or audio-tapes and verbalising material (Ward & Daley, 1993). Kinaesthetic learners use moyement and action to learn hence they prefer to write, act, pace and use gestures (Ward & Daley, 1993). In addition to the three learning styles, Discovery participants also get to understand their own preference to learning through the seven multiple intelligences. ''Multiple intelligences" provides a more diverse understanding of a way a person learns and is also provided in the study skills section of Discovery. The "multiple intelligences" are the theory of Howard Gardner (1993) and are anchored in the view that "human beings are capable of at least seven different ways of knowing the world" (p. 12). The seven intelligences Gardner ( 1993) refers to are musical, spatial, mathematical, interpersonal, intrapersonal, physical and linguistic. Each represents a way in which the individual operates depending on the task or individual preferences. An overview of each is listed as follows: musical - a person who has the capacity to perceive, appreciate and produce rhythms and melodies. They have a good ear, sing in tune and can keep time to music. spatial - a person who understands their world through pictures and images. He or she has the ability to perceive, transform and recreate. They are sensitive to 9 visual details and can visualise vividly, draw or sketch ideas graphically, and can orient themselves in 3-D space. mathematical - a person who prefers numbers and logic, has the ability to reason. and are good at sequencing with a rational outlook on life. interpersonal - these people understand and work with other people. They are responsive to moods and intentions. intrapersonal - a person who is connected with the inner self. They access their own feelings, are introspective, deep and soul-searching. They are also fiercely independent, and can work on their own successfully. physical - these people are good at handling objects and controlling body movements. They like any hands-on activity. linguistic - a person who is good with words. They have the skills in persuasion, can entertain, argue, or instruct effectively. They are usually trivia experts or masters ofliteracy. They also read voraciously and write clearly. (Discovery Study Skills Workbook) The third main study skill offered at Discovery are techniques for enhancing memory. "Memory techniques" are aimed at enhancing the learning process and include skills consistent with "multiple intelligences" and "learning styles" and involve strategies such as the use of music and colour while studying, peer tutoring, highlighting material when learning, working in a team, visualising and reading aloud. Fourthly, the skill of "speed reading" is also taught at Discovery. "Speed reading" applies to a number of skills which allows the reader to increase their speed of reading as 10 well as their comprehension on material (Ward & Daley, 1993). Eye exercises and comprehension practise help the participants to better their understanding of the material and increase their speed of reading. All these skills are taught throughout the study skill sessions of Discovery. Limitations and Delimitations of the Study The focus on studying in detail the Discovery NZ22 programme meant that to understand it fully, one had to take into account the history and development of the Discovery programme. This study therefore examined the overall development of the Discovery programme as it relates to New Zealand, with its historical development, purpose and aims, structure and content and processes involved in staff training. This provided an important background to the ov~rall development of the programme and the context in which it was introduced. It was not intended in this study, to go more deeply into details of the organisation and administration of Discovery and the Global Youth Foundation, as this study was focused mainly on the participants and their views of the programme on their development. In order to obtain a preliminary indication of participants' views to the programme, it was important to examine past participants' responses to previous questionnaires. In examining past participants' responses to previous questionnaires, only questions relevant to this study, such as skills mastered and their views on achievement, were selected as this section was a preliminary study intended to provide a basic understanding of the programme's accomplishments through the perspective of the participants. A list of responses was made through a clustering of similar remarks and some statistical tabulation was produced to illustrate and highlight some trends. It was the intention to identify parts of the programme which participants showed some degree of response; and thus provide preliminary information and directions for this study. It was not intended to focus on these results nor subject them to detailed statistical analysis. 11 The lack of literature on programmes for adolescents such as Discovery in New Zealand is not surprising considering it's recent introduction in 1991 and its previous cultural orientation. Two programmes out of the past 21 programmes for study were selected, Discovery NZ20 and NZ2 l, as preliminary data to the study as discussed above. International studies have therefore provided the basis for the literature review of educational programmes in relation to programmes such as the Discovery programme. The theoretical link of this study to Eriksons' s identity crisis of adolescence (Erikson, 1968) and Marcia's four identity statuses (Kroger, 1989) is acknowledged particularly in the adolescents' balancing between their commitment and confusion about their role in society. The link of the theoretical perspectives with this study lies with the developmental tasks spelled out in the theories by Havighurst (1972) and Newman and Newman (1995) as their tasks identify skills or roles that needs to be learned by adolescents in order to become soundly adjusted in the adult world. The Discovery programme, which is the focus of this study, addresses certain tasks and skills which contributes to the well-being and development of its participants and are delivered through the lifeskills and study skills components of its programme. Discovery's tasks and skills serve as building blocks to development in a similar way that Havighurst's (1972) and Newman and Newman's (1995) developmental tasks are identified for young people to achieve. Summary The focus of this case study was on the Discovery programme, which was introduced in New Zealand in 1991, and the contribution it makes towards the teenage participants' development. The observations made by the writer as participant observer during a previous Discovery programme in New Zealand prompted a formal study into the programme and the influence it had on the participants. 12 Erik Eriksons's psychosocial developmental theory, particularly the stage of adolescence, provides the developmental perspective of this study. Erikson refers to adolescence as a stage where the young person experiences the fifth crisis of "Identity versus Role Confusion", where identity is viewed as a balance between commitment and confusion about one's role in society (Kroger, 1989). Havighurst (1972) and Newman and Newman (1995) identified developmental tasks which related to these roles and these relate to lifeskills and study skills, which are addressed, directly and indirectly, by the Discovery programme. The rationale of this study was to obtain a clear picture of the role of the Discovery New Zealand programme in contributing to the adolescent participants' development within the New Zealand environment. The aims of the study were therefore constructed around the above mentioned rationale such that a case study of the Discovery programme was undertaken and highlighted its historical development, content, procedures and overall contribution to the teenage participants development was highlighted. This involved a preliminary examination of the Discovery programme itself and a sampling of previous participants' responses to the programme. A specific investigation into Discovery NZ22 was also undertaken and the participants' views on the contribution to their lives involving lifeskills, study skills, communication patterns with parents, overall perceptions, and adolescent issues. The terminology referring to young people aged between 12 - 22 years were defined according to Newman and Newman's (1995) characterisation of "early adolescence" (12 - 18 years) and "later adolescence" (19 - 22 years). Interchangeable terms for adolescence were also discussed. Lifeskills and study skills forms the basis of skill-training for Discovery's teenage participants. In simple terms, lifeskills was defined as processes in which chosen 13 sequences in specific psychological and social contexts are conducive to a person's well-being. Study skills refer to strategies or tips for enhancing learning. Both the lifeskills and study skills components of Discovery incorporate psychological, social, and academic learning skills. The investigation into selected aspects of the Discovery programme, prev10us participants views of Discovery, and specifically NZ22 participants' responses to its contribution in the lives of young people, emphasised a case study approach to research. The following chapter comprises a reVJew of the literature and developmental perspectives in adolescence. CHAPTER TWO REVIEW OF LITERATURE AND DEVELOPMENTAL PERSPECTIVES 14 This chapter introduces the literature on other programmes and developmental perspectives related to this study. The sections are designed to provide information of other studies related to lifeskills and study skills training. The literature pertaining to teenage issues is also reviewed including challenges in adolescence, coping, depression and parent-adolescent communication. A review of developmental perspectives in adolescence is also provided. The sections in this chapter are arranged in the following order: Lifeskills Training Programmes for Adolescents; Study Skills; Challenges in Adolescence and Adolescent Coping Ability; Depression in Adolescence; Parent-Adolescent Communication; Developmental Perspectives in Adolescence; Cognitive Learning and the Social Environment; The Period of Adolescence and the "Rites of Passage"; Societal Changes Influencing Adolescence; Conclusion. The combination of sections provided an overview of the literature relevant to the present study. Lif eskills Training Programmes for Adolescents Educational programmes for teenagers have fallen into a number of categories which either address specific groups or the general population, and either address certain topics or a generic based curriculum either in the school settings, private institutions or community based initiatives. The following two sections discuss the programmes available in New Zealand for teenagers and then the lifeskills programmes available internationally. 15 An Overview of Programmes Available for New Zealand Teenagers Teenage self development programmes have been in existence for decades in New Zealand. Examples such as Outward Bound, Outdoor Pursuits, Spirit of Adventure and the new Spirit of Youth Trust provide programmes for the teenage population to enhance self esteem and confidence. Sport, adventure and physical challenges have generally been vehicles for self development programmes for teenagers on these programmes. A variety of clubs such as Scouts and Guides, youth church groups and other community groups have also created programmes which support the teens of New Zealand society by encouraging their personal growth. However, formal evaluations and the understanding of the impact they have on their participants is scarce. Within secondary schools, the programmes provided in the curriculum have predominantly been focused around a problem-based curriculum. Alcohol, drug and teenage pregnancy programmes have been developed in response to the recent problems in teenage years. In 1997, the Ministry of Education released a draft document of the Health and Physical Education curriculum for all New Zealand schools (Ministry of Education, 1997). A trial of the curriculum took place during 1999 in various schools throughout New Zealand and has been implemented in the national curriculum over the following two years. Although it is still early days before the impact of the Health and Physical Education curriculum for teenagers is implemented and evaluated, it is a curriculum which appears to have addressed adolescent development by focusing on a number of adolescent challenges by promoting healthy living, mentally, physically, spiritually and socially. This is done through a generic curriculum of social and intrapersonal skills as well as an integration of specific topics pertinent to adolescents such as sexuality, relationships and drug abuse. The spiral curriculum also allows for the accumulation of knowledge through age-appropriate learning. 16 School-based initiatives are one way of reaching the general population of teenagers. Initiatives which enhance teenagers' psychological and social health have featured increasingly within the school environment (Taylor, 1992; Ministry of Health, 1995-1996; Hamburg, 1997). The development of public health prevention programmes for youth are ideally implemented in the school environment as they reach a large youth population. Various booklets and pamphlets about lifeskills in education have been disseminated throughout New Zealand schools to promote the successful application of these to school students (Ministry of Health, 1995-1996). Community-Based youth initiatives are somewhat more intense and usually engage the participants over shorter periods of time than schools. For some, it is better for students to learn skills outside of the school environment as school is often perceived as a negative place and inhibits rather than promotes mental health. For example, one quarter of the youth sampled in the Gordon and Grant ' s (1997) research on the psychological health of adolescents in Glasgow named "school" as a place when asked to indicate ' 'things that make me feel bad". Although not all reports about school were negative, a large number of them were. On reflection of their findings, it is unfortunate that such feelings are conjured up about an institution which plays a prominent role in teenagers' lives. Whether lifeskills training is promoted through schools or through alternative means, the programmes essentially provide a context in which the skills, necessary for the healthy development of adolescents, are being taught. However understanding the idiosyncrasies and benefits of each programmes is the next step in the formula of addressing the educational programmes available to adolescents. A Review of Lifeskills Training Programmes • International There are a number of programmes which have involved lifeskills training and have either been the total focus of programmes or existed as portion of the curriculum. Some 17 programmes have focused upon more generic skills such as communication or problem solving skills, whereas others have focused upon a curriculum associated with specific teenage problems such as suicide, teenage pregnancy or the rate of young people smoking. The following review of literature presents a combination of programmes which have been either developed within schools or through community initiatives and which have, to varying degrees, the elements of lifeskills training. An explanation of each programme is first given and then the respective studies of each programme is explained. The community based programme named Summer Training Education Programme (STEP) was developed in America to address school age pregnancy (Walker & Vilella-Velez, 1992). STEP' s long term goals were to reduce teenage pregnancy, decrease school drop-outs, improve academic skills and the chance of employment. The programme is implemented during a fifteen month period and includes two full-time Summer vacations. STEP was aimed at 14 to 15 year old disadvantaged teenagers and was designed to enhance their options for life by providing meaningful and attainable alternatives to pregnancy. In the STEP programme "disadvantaged teenagers" referred to those who were from low income families, who came from a wide ethnic and racial group, and whom had a high percentage who were already sexually active. There are four integrated components to the STEP programme of which one part, consisting of 18 hours, is devoted specifically to lifeskills training. The remaining three components consisted of work experience during the two Summers (90 hours), remediation in reading and maths (90 hours), and regular support from mentors during the school year (80 -100 hours) over the fifteen month period of the programme. The Lifeskills and Opportunity component (LSO) of STEP is designed to help young people raise their expectations for the future so they will be motivated to delay parenthood until they have achieved those goals. The combination of skills associated to 18 the preparation of employment and planning future families, addresses the heart of future prospects for adolescents. The Lifeskills and Opportunity component builds upon generic skills such as assertiveness, decision-making, communication, goal setting, and a recognition and rejection of stereotypes. Research into the effects of STEP for their participants has involved 4800 young people from five different cities who were part of either the treatment group or the control group. The research investigated whether the programmes goals, stated earlier, were upheld (Walker & Vilella-Velez, 1992). The findings showed that the effects were positive. By the end of the first Summer reading and maths scores had improved by an average of half a grade for STEP youth as compared with the control group who received only Summer jobs and no training. The STEP participants also showed more responsible sexual and social behaviour, had higher attendance rates, and attrition rates for the next Summer were high (75%). Overall, the participants became more knowledgeable of birth control and the consequences of teenage parenting, and as a consequence there was no increase in sexual activity. These findings demonstrate that the goals of the programme were in fact upheld. The Summer Training Educational Programme (STEP), especially the Lifeskills and Opportunity component, has similarities to the Discovery programme such that the mode of address allows for experiential learning since the teenagers themselves find the answers to their own questions or problems. This of course is helped by the guidance and support of trained staff members and the facilitators. Furthermore, Discovery is similar in the content of generic skills it provides as problem solving, decision making, communication, recognition and control over stereotypes and goal setting are also part of the Discovery programme. However, the difference between Discovery and the STEP programme emerges when the number of hours spent in lifeskills training is compared. Discovery is predominantly a lifeskills training programme whereas the STEP programme attributes a much smaller component of such training in its curriculum. 19 Another teenage programme, which is based upon a problem curriculum, is that of Orbach and Bar-Joseph (1993). This suicide prevention programme incorporated lifeskills training with the skills appropriate for an adolescent to deal with feelings of hopelessness, the development of ego identity, coping and suicide tendencies. The mode of implementation is introspective such that each of the seven weekly, 2 hourly sessions was constructed in such a way to elicit discussion about the participants' own emotional expenences. These shared and guided experiences were designed to emphasis the similarities of their experience, find alternative ways to solve problems and encourage a self-help and peer-help approach. The 393 participants were from six classes in six high school throughout Israel and were categorised as non-at-risk individuals except for one class which consisted of conduct disordered teens. All participants were randomly assigned to either the treatment group or the control group. The topics of the seven sessions were concentrated around depression and happiness, adolescent and the family, feelings of helplessness, coping with failure, personal perspective on coping with stress and problem solving, coping with suicidal urges, with the last session providing a summary and feedback. The impact of this programme was conducted in a pretest-posttest design using instruments which measured suicidal tendencies, ego identity, hopelessness, and coping ability. The participants' evaluation of the programme also provided further information. The posttest was given within a three week time span after the last session. The results showed the experimental group showed a significant reduction in suicidal tendencies, had an increase in ego identity cohesion and their ability to cope, and had a decrease in feelings of hopelessness (Orbach & Bar-Joseph, 1993). Also, the evaluations of the programme overall were mostly positive. One limitation of the previous study is that the programme was conducted through each school's counsellors and variance between their styles and interactions, both during and out of the session times, may have emerged. The significance of the findings showed 20 that an introspective programme effected the participants' ability to cope and shielded against self-destructive behaviours. This is significant especially in the area of suicide prevention as other programmes which were aimed toward the prevention of suicide have shown reverse results (Shaffer, Vieland, Garland, Rojas, Underwood & Busner, 1990). Orbach and Bar-Joseph (1993) have placed great importance on the type of programme and the difference it made to suicide prevention. It involves the process of exploring inner feelings and actions helps to guide and encourage the teenage participants to focus on alternative ways of doing things which are both positive and health promoting. Discovery is similar to Orbach and Bar-Joseph's programme through its introspective elements. A generic educational programme for early adolescents named Bridging the Gap was developed and implemented through the Salvation Army in eight Eastern states in America. The aims of the programme were to help young people to take charge of their own lives through self respect, to provide information about their physical and emotional needs and to have the knowledge and skills in community rights and utilising community services. These three broad curriculum areas were divided into twelve units of 90 minutes each and conducted as a community project for those who used the services of the Salvation Army. Support from parents was gained and their inclusion of parents in final ceremonies helped to open communication channels. The effect Bridging the Gap had on its participants was explored by the Salvation Army and Dr. Petersen (Hamburg, B., 1990). Information was gathered through the first and last sessions of the programme which involved the completion of a questionnaire measuring self concept, knowledge and coping skills. A control group was used to understand the effects of the programmes on it's participants. The findings showed that the youth in the Bridging the Gap program made substantial gains in knowledge about themselves, the community and it's resources (Hamburg, B., 1990). The majority of participants felt they had become more self confident and had a more positive image of 21 themselves. Overall, the participants showed positive gams in the skills area the programme provided. In a review of literature on lifeskills programmes for early adolescents, Moote and Wodarski ( 1997) found that adventure based lifeskills programmes impacted positively on the adolescents' self-concept and self-esteem. Combined with a counselling type programme, these programmes serve to benefit most of the participants in the studies reviewed. An increase in co-operative behaviours, the generalisation of adventure skills to their life areas, and positive gains on psychological, social and intellectual growth were also acknowledged. Study Skills Study skills are offered as part of the Discovery programme in recognition of the skills required by a young person in today's society. These days, it is not only important for young people to receive an education but also to succeed at school so that it increases the prospects for employment and their future. According to Crockett and Petersen ( 1993 ), study skills are essential in helping a student through schooling and exams, especially those exams which contribute toward nationally recognised qualifications. Therefore, employment opportunities are reduced for those who do not have a minimum qualification and the probability of earning a satisfactory income is somewhat lessened (Crockett & Petersen, 1993). New Zealand statistics support this as in the 1998 statistical analysis of school leavers, the highest group unemployed are those with no qualification with the next highest group being those who have only School Certificate (Statistics New Zealand~ 1998). In New Zealand the percentage of school leavers who obtained at least Sixth Form Certificate or higher has slightly decreased. In 1993, 66% of all school leavers obtained Sixth Form Certificate or higher (Ministry of Education, 1995) as compared with 64% in 22 1995 (Ministry of Education, 1997). By calculation, the remaining 97 44 have School Certificate or no such formal qualifications (Ministry of Education, 1997). The majority of leavers withdraw from school when their age no longer permits them to remain there. School was one source of stress for the fifteen year old Canadians investigated in a study by Mates and Allison (1992). The reasons for school as a contributor to stress in adolescence showed that there was considerable pressure put upon students to succeed at school which comes mainly from parent who want their child to succeed, not only at school, but in life as well. Exams are also a stressful time for teenagers and are often an instigator of negative feelings (Gordon & Grant, 1997). In a snapshot view of feelings, fifteen year olds from nearly all the high schools in Glasgow, on a designated day, were invited to write about "how it is to be you today". Many students chose to reflect on school. The feelings related to school were mostly negative referring to boredom, doing badly in school, stressful place to be, tests/exams, teachers, homework and peers. Increasing the prospects of the future in regard to employment opportunities undoubtedly promotes the positive development of an adolescent. Supplementary programmes which provide additional skills for learning and increasing the prospects of the future have already been discussed. One such intervention was the STEP programme which provided literacy and numeracy skills to the participants of the programmes (Walker & Vilella-Velez, 1992). These skills, along with the mentoring assistance and opportunity to work, helped the teenagers gain better grades in reading and writing and all had higher attendance rates at school. The interest for the present study is in finding out whether the study skills taught at Discovery were useful or not and whether the perception of their study skills had, in their 23 view, improved. It was presumed that good study skills lead towards better academic results in the future. Challenges in Adolescence and Adolescent Coping Ability The period of adolescence provides the opportunity for young people to explore their world and discover their role in society as it fits for them. In doing so the adolescent may be faced with many challenges and sources of stress as they move through the tasks associated with adolescence. A number of challenges and stresses can be identified within adolescence as the following review of literature shows. Peers, teachers, and especially parents were found to be major stresses in a number of studies (Moore, 1997; Morris, 1985; Patten, 1988), as so was finding a job (Silva, 1989; Morris, 1985). The threat of war especially nuclear war was particularly disturbing for teenagers in the study by Silva (1989) which focused on Otago teenagers. Other challenges that created stresses in young peoples lives were school achievement (Moore, 1997; Morris, 1985; Silva, 1989), coping with their own physical development (Morris, 1985; Maskill, 1991), body size, especially for girls (Moore, 1997), sexual orientation (Moore, 1997), moving house or places (Morris, 1985). Such stresses may be either prolonged or intermittent (Nicol, 1987). Mortality issues are a major stress for young people as a number of studies have shown. In a large sample of Wellington secondary school students, Patten (1988) reported the teenage participants rated highly the fear of their own death. In the same study the death of a family member or fiiend was also rated highly in their fears (Patten, 1988). Death was the concern of a large number of adolescents in another study (Nicol, 1987). Other studies have shown similar findings with the addition of the feeling of stress about their own health (Morris, 1985; Moore, 1997; Nicol, 1987). 24 A number of major sources of stress were reported in Mates & Allison'-s (1992) study of 15 year old participants. The teenage participants, who were from three Toronto high schools, were asked a number of questions through focus group interviews and identified major stresses such as relationships with parents and family, work and lack of money. Other responses given by some of the 15 year olds as stresses were friends, school, gangs or strangers, addictions/drugs and the pressure to drink, smoke or use drugs. When the 23 participants were asked how someone their age would deal with or cope with a number of problems, their responses showed that their coping mechanisms involved substance use (drinking alcohol, smoking cigarettes, and using drugs) and diversionary tactics such as relaxing, playing sports, listening to music, or playing an instrument. Rebellious responses were also given for coping with challenges such as being reckless or telling lies. Mates and Allison's (1992) study is particularly important as it provides a guideline for the responses to challenges in adolescence given by the teenage participants at Discovery. Different reports of concerns emerge when the age of the young person is studied. For example, Violato and Holden (1992) found those in younger adolescence (11 - 14 years) were more concerned about smoking whereas older adolescents referred to challenges with drugs and other substances. The same study showed that during the middle ages of early adolescence, 14 to 15 years, there was an increase in concerns about peer acceptance and relationships with friends (Violato & Holden, 1988). Self esteem issues were also raised at this age (Levenson, Morrow, Johnson & Pfefferbaum, 198~) - For older adolescents, the focus of concerns was upon school and academic performance, which in developmental terms, impinges upon vocational security and career plans (Violota & Holden, 1988). Gender differences were analysed in a study by Plancheral and Bolognini (1995) which examined the responses to coping with challenges in early adolescence. It was reported that young females invest in social activities, express more negative feelings, and adopt 25 consumption habits such as shopping or eating as coping strategies. Young males on the other hand, invest in hobbies or sport and use a sense of humour to cope. One study relevant to the present research investigated a psycho-educational intervention for the effects on teenage coping abilities. Rice, Herman and Petersen (1993) theories in coping with challenges in early adolescence were examined through a psycho-educational programme. The purpose of the programme was to intervene in the developmental process by helping young adolescents learn effective coping responses to the challenges that arise. Feelings of being depressed were also investigated in Rice, Herman and Petersen's study. The intervention programme introduced by Rice, Herman and Petersen ( 1993) to the teenage participants, takes the interpersonal approach to teaching adaptive emotional, cognitive, and behavioural responses to stresses and challenges. This programme involved 16 sessions conducted for 40 minutes over a period of eight weeks. Each of the 16 session focused on a particular social skill, coping method or challenge. The teaching of skills begins through a group discussion, followed by the formal teaching of a skill and modelling of the skill, then ends with the adolescents themselves practising and integrating the skill into their lives experientially. This programme was implemented through the school environment and conducted during school hours with small groups (8-12 members). A parent-training component is also part of this intervention and is run concurrently with the teen programme. Participants of the programme by Rice, Herman and Petersen (1993) were recruited from two communities with approximately equal number of boys and girls. The participants consisted of 151 adolescent, 121 mothers and 93 fathers. Less than one third of the adolescents were identified as high-risk for developing depression from a self report measure completed prior to the programme' s start. Preliminary findings showed the programme helped to increase the quality of family relations and decrease negative life 26 events. The adolescent control group reported the opposite on both accounts. Also participants of the programme indicated significant increases in perceived coping abilities and control over challenges at school and interpersonal situations whereas the control group had no such effects. A positive effect of the intervention was reported as a significant decrease in negative life events from pretest to post-test as compared to the increase of such events for the control group. Miller, Meyer, Grund and Herman (1992) assessed the short term proximal effects of on coping and social abilities on the same psycho-educational intervention as above, and with the same groups of teenagers. Participants in the intervention reported significant increases in perceived coping abilities and perceived control over challenging school and interpersonal events, and relationships with peers and family improved. This is different to the control group who showed no such effects and even declined in the quality of their family relationships. The challenges which face young people were investigated in the present study as so was their ability to cope with such challenges. An exploration of Discovery's influence on such situations was explored through the teenagers views. In no way was this exploration intended to address the treatment of coping in adolescence. Instead the issue of coping with challenges was explored in regard to the overall development of the adolescent. Depression in Adolescence Depression is prevalent during adolescence and can potentially develop into a health problem during the teenage years (Andrews & Merry, 1998; Rutter, 1986; Reynolds, 1992; Shaffer, 1986; Kosky, Silburn & Zubrick, 1986; Marcotte, 1996). In an overview of the prevalence of depression in adolescence, on studies carried out on broad samples of New Zealand, US and UK teenagers., Andrews & Merry (1998) reported that at any one time between 0.7% and 3.4% of teenagers are depressed. In a "community study of 27 Christchurch teenagers found that 3 .1 % of 15 year olds displayed depression whereas 16.7% of 18 year olds had depression" (Andews & Merry, 1998, p. 21). More specifically, if depressive symptoms are analysed for teenagers over the last 12 months, the rate of depression becomes much higher. Andrews and Merry (1998) noted that between 2.7% and 16.7% of the adolescent population in New Zealand recorded enough symptoms for a diagnosis of depression (Andrews & Merry, 1998). With the knowledge about the prevalence of depression in the adolescent years, this study examined the participants' views about the influence Discovery may have on depression. Bird and Drewery (2000) briefly addressed the issue of depression in the teenage population in New Zealand. The number of young people affected varies considerably with symptoms including low moods, diminished interest in going out, significant weight loss or gain and sleeping problems including too much or too little. They stress that depression does not necessarily lasts forever although once you have had one episode it is more likely that you will have another. According to Silva (1988), the psychological health of adolescence is the most common, and the most debilitating, health problem for people in this age group. The most common health disorders found by Silva (1988) in New Zealand adolescents were depression, conduct disorder and substance abuse. School was also a source of stress reported by the teenagers of the same study. It was found that 10% of adolescents in the general population of New Zealand had a definable mental health disorder at any one time. In a study by Schichor, Bernstein and King (1994), 595 of the 966 (approximately 60%) who responded to a questionnaire indicated that they had been depressed or felt down to some degree, with females twice as likely to report such states. This group of teenagers, with a mean age of 15. 5 years, were given a screening questionnaire soliciting information about their general health, home, school, reproductive health, mental health, 28 and exposure to drugs and alcohol during their routine visit to a medical centre. All teens were asked it they had ever felt down or depressed, and if so, the frequency of such feelings. The teenage participants were also asked to report if they could relate to any of the problems that were listed in the questionnaire. Those who identified as having felt down or depressed at some stage clearly identified more problems than those who never felt down or depressed. Although some symptoms identified were physical such as "pain in your legs" or "skin or complexion problems" the most significant correlation of problems identified by those who indicated they have felt down or depressed were psychosocial in nature. The six problem types reported were "trouble with your parent understanding you", "worried about the future", "worried about sex or pregnancy", "trouble making or keeping friends", "worried about parents" and "worried about a place to live". In addition to the profile of those who have felt depressed or down, these teenagers were also the group who were three times more likely to have experienced suicide ideation, and seven times as likely to have reported a suicide attempt. The psychosocial nature of the problems identified by the teenagers in Schichor, Bernstein and King's (1994) study help to explain the situations in which teenage depression comes about. The reasons for a teenager being depressed are investigated in the present study through a teenage perspective as well as the skills and strategies Discovery may provide for young people to prevent or limit depression. Gordon and Grant's ( 1997) study of secondary students aged between 13 and 14 years, mentioned previously, responded to questions about how they felt on the day designated for the questionnaire to be completed. Nineteen percent of students said they felt depressed giving explanations of"feeling low", ''feeling down", ''bad attitude", and being "sad". The importance of the questionnaire given by Gordon and Grant (1997) was that it elicited the teenagers own responses and feelings through the series of questions asked about their mental health. 29 The researcher's intention to explore issues of adolescent depression in the present study was to find out the participants views of depression with no intention of addressing the treatment. A number of research questions were designed merely to become aware of the participants' views as it relates to their developmental tasks and development. Parent-Adolescent Communication The transition from adolescence to adulthood is a potentially stressful time not only for adolescents but also for parents. As the adolescent finds their own identity, the family requires a realignment in family relationships. In order for this to happen successfully there must be effective communication. Noller and Callan (1991) are convinced that effective communication is the medium to good relationships within a family. The ideal family environment for adolescents, suggested by Noller and Callan (1991), is one where communication is positive and effective, where adolescents receive strong support from their parents, feel free to express their feelings and opinions appropriately, and to discuss issues, raise conflicts, negotiate about plans and make decisions. Positive, effective communication in the family, especially between parents and their children, is crucial in the functioning of the family and the well-being of adolescents. Communication affects the quality of the relationship between the parents and the healthy functioning of the family, both as a whole, and individually. Open communication between adolescents and between them and their adult caregivers is imperative as Nelson, Farberow and Litman (1988) discovered in their study of prevention of youth suicide. Their research focused on a combined group of 12 - 20 year olds, parents of suicide victims, and profiles of the suicide victims prior to their suicide. The study showed all groups within the study indicated communication problems as a factor possibly contributing toward suicide. Furthermore, "having someone to talk to,, was identified by the young people as a preventative measure for suicide. 30 Barnes and Olson (1985) tested 426 families, consisting of at least one adolescent and one parent, for their communication patterns between parent and adolescent. These families were classified as intact, meaning the vast majority of parents were not divorced (96%) and were without any serious problems. The adolescents consisted of equal male and females and with an average age of 16.4 years. The instrument used for exploring communication levels in the family was the Parent-Adolescent Communication Scale. The results showed mothers reported better communication with their child than fathers due to the higher levels of openness reported between mother and child. As a group, teenagers reported difficulty communicating with their parents. Both parents reported significantly more openness and fewer problems in communication with their child. In contrast to the parents views, the teenagers viewed their intrafamily communication with much greater negativism. Parent-Adolescent Communication was also investigated in a study by Noller and Bagi ( 1985). Frequency, initiation, recognition, self-disclosure, domination and satisfaction were dimensions of communication investigated in 58 families with at least one adolescent who ranged in age from 16 to 20 years and who lived at home with their parents and who attended university. The results showed that the teens tended to communicate more with mothers than fathers over a wide range of topics. One exception to this was the topic of politics in which teens engaged in communication with fathers on this topic. More self-disclosure was related to mothers than to fathers, with daughter disclosing more to mothers than did sons. Parental control was examined in a study by Smetana (1988). Both the adolescents and parents views were sought in regard to control over certain issues relating to moral, conventional and personal issues. As expected, parent perceived issues as more under their authority than their children. Moral and conventional issues were in parental control however parents also wanted to take control over personal issues as well caused some conflict with their adolescent. 31 The present study examined communication between the participating teenagers of Discovery and their parents. A diagnostic tool for communication was used to investigate the changes in communication patterns. Comparisons of communication before and after Discovery revealed any changes that took place and highlighted the effects of Discovery. Developmental Perspectives of Adolescence The Discovery programme is directed at adolescents from ages 13 -18 years. It addresses lifeskills and study skills which aim to contribute to the young person's well-being and psychosocial development. One well known theorist in human development is Erik Erikson who has defined 8 developmental stages in a lifespan (Erikson, 1963). In each stage the individual is required to resolve conflicts in order to adjust to the psychological demands placed upon them by society. In Erikson's theory of development, societal expectations guide the individual into behaving in certain ways. According to Erikson (1963) "adolescence'', the fifth stage of his theory, is a crucial time for identity development where the young person wants to establish and know himself or herself as a specific individual, to maintain some connection with the meaningful elements of the past, and to accept the values of a group. It is in this period of life that the adolescent is faced with resolving the conflict of forming their own identity or risk identity confusion. The process of identity formation is marked with a variety of changes such as experimentation with various roles, sorting out the likes and dislikes of the role, making important decisions pertaining to their career, making political commitments and an increased interest in world affairs. All these developmental changes helps the adolescent make a commitment towards their own identity and a resolution of the conflict. An adolescent who achieves an identity for themselves, has a new and refreshing sense of self; one which is acceptable within their social environment. On the other hand, the 32 adolescent who unsuccessfully resolves the identity crisis, suffers from the confusion of who they really are with regard to their own beliefs, values, thoughts and possible future. Such adolescents are likely to either withdraw and isolate themselves from their family and peers or totally lose their identity within their social environment. Erikson's emphasis on identity development during the years of adolescence has been the basis of studies by James Marcia. Marcia ( 196 7) expanded Erikson's concept of an identity crisis by categorising adolescent development into four identity statuses: identity confused/diffused, foreclosure, moratorium and identity achieved. All of these involve both a crisis and commitment on the part of the individual. The first category which describes the young person as identity confused, is one who has not yet experienced a crisis or made any commitment to a vocation or set of beliefs. In other words, the adolescent has not developed a commitment to anything, instead they continue in their childlike activities, thinking and status. The second facet of adolescent development, foreclosure, discusses the adolescent in a situation upon which an identity has not been explored or formed by the adolescent themselves. Instead, the adolescent has taken upon an identity which has been handed to them, usually by their parents. The adolescent in this state has experienced commitment, but has not experienced a "crisis" and therefore takes upon the values, beliefs and vocation that they have known all their lives or what has been decided for them. If the adolescent does not sufficiently challenge their environments then foreclosure may become permanent and they will remain dependent on others (Kroger, 1989). In contrast to the foreclosure adolescent, the third identity status identified by Marcia, named moratorium, allows the adolescent to explore and actively search for alternates to what they have already experienced and know. Therefore, the adolescent is in an acute state of crisis, struggling to find their identity. They are usually rebellious and less co-operative with authority, they challenge most things, and they try out different roles 33 to ascertain what they like or dislike in order to make a final commitment to their identity. In accordance with Erikson's developmental perspective also, this stage is important for the identity development of an individual such that the person is able to experiment with alternative identities without trying to settle on any one (Erikson, 1968). However, this becomes destructive when the person reaches the age maturity of adulthood without having made adult commitments such as choosing a lifestyle, a vocation, an ideology or even a partner. A final commitment to a identity is not part of the moratorium process. However, moratorium is a pre-requisite to the fourth and final concept of Marcia's theory, the identity achieved adolescent. The adolescent in this category is one who has made a commitment to an identity which has developed from the moratorium stage as well as past experiences. Therefore, identity achievement is a synthesis of the past and the projected future. It is from this anchor of self acceptance and a stable self definition that the adolescent has made a sound commitment toward a role in society with adult status, and hence, found their own identity. Marcia's identity statuses of adolescent development are transient in nature such that an individual may involve alternating the statuses at different times before perhaps achieving a status of identity achieved (Kroger, 1989). Not all theories follow this pattern. The present study acknowledges the importance of Erikson's theory of an identity crisis and Marcia's expansion by identifying identity statuses in as much as the Discovery programme contributes to the young person's learning of skills related to one's role and identity. Within the same psychosocial perspective of adolescence, Havighurst (1955) specified a set of development tasks to be achieved. According to Havighurst, a developmental 34 task, as previously defined in Chapter One, is a combination of"an individual need and a societal demand" (Havighurst, 1948, p.vi). Within Havighurst's theory of adolescence there are eight stages necessary for the healthy development of an adolescent. Each stage is thought to be brought about by certain elements such as biological maturation, one's own motivation or through societal requirements. When each one of the elements are "ripe", then it is the appropriate time for the task to be learned, or what Havighurst coins as "the teachable moment" (Havighurst, 1948, p. 7). Any effort to move the individual to the next developmental stage prior to the "teachable moment" would prove fruitless (Havighurst, 1948). The purpose of education therefore is to act as a medium in which the individual can be helped to achieve certain developmental tasks. The eight tasks of adolescent development and those acquired through infancy and childhood, help the individual to form their identity. Each of the eight developmental tasks in adolescence are designed from specific goals deemed by Havighurst as necessary in the transition from childhood to adulthood. Each goal is explained after each developmental task. The eight tasks and their goals involve the following developmental elements: 1. Achieving new and more mature relations with age mates of both sexes Gotd: To learn to look upon girls as women and boys as men; to become an adult among adults 2. Achieving a masculine or feminine social role Goal: To accept and to learn a socially approved adults masculine or feminine social roles 3. Accepting one's physique and using the body effectively Goal: To become proud, or at least tolerant, of one's body 4. Achieving emotional independence from parents and other adults Goal: To become free from childish dependence on one's parents; to develop affection for one's parents without remaining dependent upon them 5. Preparing for marriage and family life Goal: To develop a positive attitude toward family life and having children 6. Preparing for an economic future Goal: To organise one's plans and energies in such a way as to begin an orderly career; to feel able to make a living 7. Acquiring a set of values and an ethical system as a guide to behaviour - developing an ideology Goal: To form a socio-politico-ethical ideology 8. Desiring and achieving socially responsible behaviour Goal: To develop a social ideology; to participate as responsible adult in the life of the community; to take account of the values of society in one's personal behaviour (Havighurst, 1972) 35 Like Havighurst, Newman and Newman (1995) also developed the concept of developmental tasks and divided the concept of Erikson's identity developm~nt into two stages reflecting "early adolescence" and "later adolescence". The first conflict, identity versus alienation, refers to early adolescence (12 - 18 years) and is a stage which is strongly influenced by the peer group. The psychological crisis within this first stage requires the adolescent to identify with a specific peer group or risk being alienated altogether. According to Newman and Newman (1995) the psychological crisis has developed from the pressure within the family, school and age peers to conform to the peer group in order to prevent alienation. Newman and Newman (1995) outline a number of developmental tasks that occur during "early adolescence": physical maturation, formal operations, emotional development, experiencing membership in a peer group, sexual relationships. 36 ''Physical maturation" is the first developmental task which impacts upon the self image of the teenager as well as the nature of peer relationships. For example, girls mature earlier than boys and therefore the young female shows physical size differences amongst her male and female peers causing the likelihood of alienation. ''Formal operations'' is the second development task which invites more complex thinking. This gives way to the shift of thinking about the complexity of the new, more mature environment and what it offers. It is also a time when the child reminisces about childhood activities that no longer exist. "Emotional development" refers to the psychological adjustment required to master the new tasks. It is also time when the young person becomes more aware of their emotions and the variety of such emotions. As the mastery of new tasks is being met, so is the need to acquire skills relating to new feelings and emotions brought about in adolescence. The next developmental stage within early adolescence is the need for "membership in a peer group". This involves learning various social skills in which the peer group provides the shaping of appropriate behaviours through negative and positive reinforcement. Newman and Newman (1995) give the example of drug use as a behaviour motivated by a need for peer acceptance and a desire to conform to peer group norms. The last developmental stage within the 12 - 18 year age group, and coincides with the beginning of the next stage, "later adolescence", refers to "sexual relationships". As the teenager matures an interest in the opposite sex increases. This may be a time where the adolescent begins dating which enhances sex role identity and reflects upon their social status and membership in the peer group. The progress of an adolescent through the past five stages allows the adolescent to become more socially acceptable in an adult society. However, before this happens, further developmental stages are required throughout "later adolescence". Newman and Newman's (1995) second stage of adolescent development occurs in the later teen years at which the psychological crisis of identity versus role diffusion emerges. 37 Four developmental tasks exist in this stage of development: autonomy from parents, gender identity, internalised morality, and career choice. At first, establishing "autonomy from parents" is important as the child moves away from their adult caregivers and learns independence in various ways such as money handling, cooking, buying and/or driving a car. Often during this time the young person has little contact with their parents showing the sign of their growing independence. The second developmental task in "later adolescence" is "gender identity". This is where the adolescent is socialised into appropriate sex roles through a usually sex-appropriate career and holding a steady job giving the skills of providing for others such as a family in the future. "Internalised morality" meaning the formation of one's own morals follows the second developmental task in "later adolescence". This stage conceptualises Kohlberg ( 1964) theory in which there are three stages of moral development. The pre-conventional stage (approximately 4 -10 years) is where the child accepts adults morals much like the foreclosure stage of Marcia's. The second stage of moral development named the conventional stage, usually occurring around the ages of 10 - 16 years, relates to the more conscious maintenance of their existing structure and respect for authority and morals. The third stage, post conventional (16 - 25 years), activates the awareness of their own values which helps to generate a commitment to either a universal or newly-developed personal set of values and morals. In some cases this may be a reorientation and reconciliation of their previous values and morals yet incorporating their individual integrity combined with Social necessity. The three stages of Kohlberg's (1964) moral development are integrated into Newman and Newman's (1995) third stage of development in the adolescent's later years. Although it is likely that the older adolescent may have passed through at least one earlier stage of moral development as described by Kohlberg, the progression to the third stage of post-conventional moral development requires the synthesis of the two earlier stages for moral development to be finalised. 38 The last of Newman and Newman's (1995) developmental tasks is "career choice". This involves a long term decision in a career choice and is compounded by decisions about the effort needed for their career which involves whether they opt for direct entry into the workforce earning immediate rewards or delay entry by studying toward a long term career goal. Decisions of salary expectations, job satisfaction, lifestyle, rewards and routines all need to be taken into account in career choice or planning. It is only after this stage of adolescent development that Newman and Newman (1995) considers the individual to have formed an identity, providing the conflicts have been resolved and the adolescent has successfully progressed through each stage, that they are ready and equipped for an adult place in society and that society will accept them as such. The theories and concepts presented in the present study all have certain features in common. All approaches have been organised around the concept of identity development in adolescence and have a psychosocial perspective. Forming a new "sense of self' has been crucial in the theories presented and have been the underlying challenge of adolescents. Another commonality has been the theories of adolescence are developmental. This requires an incremental perspective of a person and not a static or predisposed view of what constitutes a person. Therefore, the forming of an identity is a developmental process involving the reorganisation of past experiences and associated developmental tasks in order to equip the individual with the psychological and social growth necessary for the present as well as their future. Cognitive Learning and the Social Environment The readiness to learn certain developmental tasks is dependent upon the individual's zone of learning. Similar to Havighurst's notion of the ''teachable moment", the Vygotskian theory of learning involves a more cognitive approach to attaining skills. According to Vygotsky, cognitive development moves forward largely because the individual is in a world that provides assistance when the child needs it and can benefit from it. The responsive social world lets the adolescent solve for themselves the 39 problems that they can handle. Critical development occurs with tasks that are not too easy but one that the adolescent can do with assistance. The responsive social world provides the assistance on these tasks that are within the child' s "zone of proximal development" according to Vygotskian theory (Miller, 1993). This "zone" is defined as behaviours beyond a child' s level of autonomous functioning, but within reach with the assistance of others. People learn how to perform tasks within their "zone" by interacting with more competent and responsive others who provide them with cues, hints, prompts and assistance on an as-needed basis. Such assistance lead5 to autonomous functioning and competency of the task, however without the stimulation of the supportive interactions with others autonomous functioning is impossible. The type of instruction used in the supportive social environment is one which uses a scaffolding approach (Wood, Bruner & Ross, 1976). Scaffolding, as the name suggests, is used when a building is being erected and is gradually removed as the building becomes self-supportive. This is the type of approach used in learning also when an adult provides hints and prompts for the young person to learn a task. Scaffolding, is seen by Rosenshine and Meister (1992) as an effective tool for teaching higher level cognitive strategies. In their review of numerous studies of students who had successfully been taught cognitive strategies, it was apparent that scaffolding was used frequently by these teachers. "Scaffolds are forms of support provided by the teacher (or another student) to help students bridge the gap between their current abilities and the intended goal" (Rosenshine & Meister, 1992, p. 26). Scaffolds are effective because they provide support for the student, but they do not specify each and every step to be taken, thus allowing for the student to adjust and formulate their own effective strategies that they will be motivated to use. 40 Societal Changes Influencing Adolescence Physical, social and emotional changes throughout adolescence can be a stressful and extremely challenging time for many New Zealand teenagers. In a fast changing society, such as today' s society, these issues are heightened. Different pressures, stresses and an uncertainty of a future bear upon today' s teenagers whereas perhaps in their grandparents' or even their parents' time these pressures did not exist, or certainly not to the extent they are today (Hamburg, B. , 1990). From Hamburg' s perspective, these pressures are described in the following paragraphs. The function of the family and the role of adolescence has changed strikingly over the last century. Traditionally, family relationships provided powerful organising principles. Families were once the focus of education, social and economic activity. Through the gradual process of parental guidance and teachings, children grew up learning the tasks and roles that would be required of them and knowing what their opportunities would be as adults, both in economic and emotional terms. Nowadays, the family has been made to forfeit some of these roles due to the pressures and demands our rapidly changing society exerts upon the family unit. As the family ' s role has changed, so too has the role of adolescence. As the industrial revolution developed, the opportunity for work no longer resided within the family and so the growing child lost the opportunity to observe, imitate and learn important factors related to future opportunities. As machine-related productivity and the need for human labour diminished, adolescents could not readily be absorbed into the job market and therefore were forced to gaining a formal education. Education became compulsory and took the role of educating the young person so that they could cope with the tasks of the industrialised world. Thus adolescence was a time for formal education and when the necessary skills and knowledge for a sound vocation were obtained. 41 In the past, a clear future pathway was built into childhood experiences. The child and adolescent would continuously, yet gradually, observe and imitate the adults in their environment learning the skills necessary for survival in an adult world. Then, the skills were learned in relation to an environment that changed only very slowly and could be understood as well as circumstances would permit. Children and adolescents could build a solid foundation on which they could make a contribution, earn respect and find satisfaction as adults. Now, with the rapidity of change, the prolongation of education, and the scale and complexity of society, the future is less clear (Hamburg, B., 1990). Opportunities for young person to gain the social, psychological and moral skills required for adulthood no longer comes entirely form the family. Likewise, the traditional fonnal education system did not meet the holistic skills required for the healthy development of an adolescent. The lifeskills training and social support systems that were built into the teachings of the family over the years can no longer be taken for granted. There is now a requirement to teach the skills that are missing. In the last few decades, the skills necessary for the healthy development of the adolescent have been the focus of extra-curricula or tailored programmes. The new and immediate demands for appropriate education and socialisation of youth to prepare them for productive and satisfying roles in the future have begun to be met. Educational programmes, both within and outside the traditional school setting, have taken the role to provide, or at least supplement, the life skills and social skills training that once was the role of the family. This present research focused on one such educational programme which provides lifeskills training (including social skills training) and study skills training for teenagers. Therefore an understanding of Discovery and the role it plays in skill-training for 42 adolescents is important as the changing role of society and the role of educational programmes promotes such programmes. The Period of Adolescence and the "Rites of Passage" As our society has changed, the period of adolescence has become less defined and there is no clear cut passage from childhood to adulthood. Instead, there is a period which is prolonged with activities that simulate adult status yet without a distinctive point of arrival of an adult. In Western society there is a gradual recognition of a person' s competencies which introduces a child into adulthood. For example, intellectual competencies are marked with the acceptance into intermediate school, high school, and for some, tertiary education. There are also events which signify the transition into adulthood such as the permission to leave school, the attainment of a driver' s license and to get married without parental consent at 16 years, to be able to vote at 18 years (Statistics New Zealand, 1999) and to be allowed to buy or drink liquor at 18 years of age also (New Zealand Statues, 1999). However, the fact that these events are stretched out over a period of time makes the change in status less clearly defined than it is for other cultures. Arnold Van Gennep, an anthropologist, was the first person to report the phenomenon he named the '"rites of passage". Van Gennep ( 1960) describes the "rites of passage" as ritual celebrations of a new life role, that it is designed to smooth the transition from one status or role to another. Simply put, to mark the transition from childhood to adulthood. In tribal cultures such as Africa, the "rites of passage" is inaugurated by puberty changes and initiation ceremonies undertaken to mark the "coming" of maturity. This period is a distinct, discontinuous event in a young persons life. When the young person returns home to the village and family after the ceremony, they immediately assume adult status 43 in the community. Although puberty may initiate such ceremonies, Van Gennep (1960) argues such festivities also function for social and psychological adjustment. In Western culture the transition from childhood to adulthood has been a more gradual and continuous transition than the discontinuous and distinct period of coming into adulthood as in tribal cultures. Many argue this period in Western cultures has become increasingly prolonged (Muus, 1970; Newman & Newman, 1979; Hamburg, B., 1990; Hamburg & Takanishi, 1989). Whether the "rites of passage" is discontinuous as in tribal cultures or continuous as in Western culture, it is the education that takes place in this period that is important. The educational component of a "rites of passage" represents society's way of acknowledging the timely characteristics of human development. The "rites of passage" has the function of transmitting knowledge about sexuality, providing training in adult skills, functions and tasks, and a passing of "lore of the tribe" including the socialisation of the young person into adult status. The "rites of passage" not only teaches behavioural skills but also provides a role in the social, psychological and moral adjustment of a young person (Van Gennep, 1960). For the young person, it is less clear to them how they can be useful, earn respect and be a productive part of society without the education process. The skills associated to the "rites of passage" training is imperative for the healthy and holistic development of the young person. The less uncertain or ambiguous the transition from childhood into adulthood, the more positive opportunity the adolescent has in making assumptions about themselves, their future and their social environment. Conclusion The present study offers the perspective of teenage development, from an educational point of view, by examining a lifeskills and study skills community based programme for 44 New Zealand teenagers. Lifeskills training offers the individual an invitation to accept responsibility in their lives as well as tools to help themselves at their stage of development. Little research within New Zealand and around the world has been formally conducted on programmes offered to teenagers. This research endeavours to remedy this and seeks to understand the contribution Discovery makes in the participating teenagers' lives. Lifeskills, study skills, communication with parents and views on adolescent issues including depression and coping strategies, were the areas chosen to be investigated in this study. These areas of skill are important in adolescence and contribute to the healthy development of young people. How an adult functions and fits into the requests of society is a consequence of adolescent development. The healthy psychological and social development of an adolescent is therefore important. Through the teenage years the challenges and stresses facing an adolescent can often be the cause of an adolescent engaging in inappropriate behaviours which are unacceptable in society's standards. Teenagers' feelings towards stresses and challenges in their lives often determine the level of such behaviours. The developmental perspectives presented in this chapter stemmed mainly from the Eriksonian tradition which included Marcia's extension of identity statuses and Havighurst's (1972) and Newman and Newman's (1995) developmental tasks. The process of adolescence involved the learning of a number of skills which the young person needs to master before moving onto the next area of skill, and, true to developmental theory, the tasks impact upon the following stages of development whether positively or negatively, depending if these skills have, or have not, been mastered. So what becomes important, from a developmental perspective, is that these skills are mastered at the optimal time of normal development. 45 Due to the changing role of the family, the skills necessary for the development of a young person into adulthood are not being taught. What would have been taught within in the family boundaries in a once slow changing society, is now being taught through educational programmes which address the deficiencies our teen