Massey Documents by Type

Permanent URI for this communityhttps://mro.massey.ac.nz/handle/10179/294

Browse

Filters

2014 - 201922020 - 20221

Settings

Has files: YesSubject: search.filters.subject.Christchurch Earthquake, N.Z., 2011

Search Results

Now showing 1 - 3 of 3
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Planning in the front end of flagship projects post-disaster : a Canterbury earthquake study : a thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Construction Management at Massey University, Albany, New Zealand
    (Massey University, 2022) Rodrigo, Witharanage Lourdes Niransha
    In the recent past, governments around the world have been using large public-funded projects to rebuild their disaster-stricken cities. Large public-builds, better known as flagship projects, have come under scrutiny due to unfavourable project outcomes. The continuity to under-deliver expected outcomes leaves a question about the relevance of flagship projects. Governments around the world continue to invest millions of taxpayer money into large builds. Marysville - a rural town in Victoria, Australia, spent a similar proportion on flagship projects to Christchurch following the Black-Saturday bushfires. Flagship projects post-disaster rarely attract favourable attention. There has been no previous research that explores the outcomes or the root cause of the negative impacts of flagship projects. Ten years post-disaster Marysville flagship projects have not been assessed to check the outcomes against objectives. Driven by the lack of research into flagship project outcomes and their causes, the researcher intends to understand how planning in the front end affects flagship projects in post-disaster rebuilding. The findings will be used to produce a set of guidelines for the planning of future post-disaster flagship projects. The researcher intends to assist government planners in determining if flagship projects would support rebuilding post-disaster by following the guidelines generated using the data of this study. The researcher used a case study approach to fulfill the research aim. A pilot study in Marysville, Australia, using a Grounded Theory approach, revealed that most factors that cause adverse project outcomes are linked to the planning in the front end. The study findings showed that top-level governance arrangements, early planning, and stakeholder management in Front-End Planning have a significant impact on project outcomes. A data-driven model obtained through the analysis formed the basis of the main study. The main literature study was conducted in phases to eliminate bias that could potentially affect Grounded Theory data analysis. The process revealed that pilot study data influenced a revision to the traditional Font-End Planning process. Marysville pilot study revealed that government project planning officials spent time understanding the situation created by the disaster. This activity appeared ahead of the feasibility phase. A modified version of the model included pre-feasibility, feasibility, concept, and detailed scope stages as phases of the Front-End Planning process. The findings informed the differences between routine and post-disaster public projects in the Front end Planning process. The data suggested that Stakeholder Management is a cross-phase activity starting at inception and continues right through to the detailed scope stage and beyond. The main research study was focused on three flagship projects in the Central Business District of Christchurch. The city faced a devastating sequence of earthquakes in 2010-2011 that had scrapped the city of its key buildings. The government planning officials put in place a strategy to rebuild through 17 flagship projects. The researcher adopted a qualitative method that used face-to-face interviewer data to explore three projects to achieve research objectives. The FEP process criteria identified through the pilot study and the previous literature were then applied to the case studies. The researcher adopted a qualitative study approach to construct the theory and used semi-structured face-to-face interviews as the data collection method. Thirty-four expert respondents were interviewed. The interviewees covered all major stakeholder categories for flagship projects in Christchurch, and they belonged to the highest level of decision-makers in their organisations, except for the frequent users of the public facilities in question. The data gathered through the case studies revealed that the projects that more or less followed all of the proposed steps in the front-end planning process had better project outcomes. Some of the adverse outcomes of the projects that followed the FEP process thoroughly still had some negative impacts. The negative impacts were caused by external factors outside of the control of the project owners. Governance at the portfolio level seems to have a lesser effect on projects that were fully Crown-funded. Large projects that allow sufficient time for FEP, specifically in the Pre-feasibility phase, feasibility phase, concept phase, and detailed scope phase seem to avoid detrimental project outcomes. A set of planning guidelines for future government planning officials has been formulated based on the evidence of the case studies. The guidelines address all four areas of the FEP process and follow the process revealed within the study. The research fills the gap where Emergency management frameworks/guidelines only consider immediate recovery following large-scale disasters. Unlike other planning guidelines, the guidelines produced as the output of this study appreciates the effect different governance arrangements may have on the planning of large public projects. With an understanding of governance arrangements post-disaster, the guidelines can be altered and used as a guide to inform better decision-making regarding large public builds post-disaster.
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    The prenatal effects of the Christchurch earthquake on executive function at five years of age : a thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Masters of Educational Psychology at Massey University
    (Massey University, 2017) Dobson, Erin M
    Despite the frequency of earthquakes, particularly in New Zealand, little is known about the long-term effects that they can have on vulnerable populations, such as mothers and unborn babies. This study looks at the way in which a major earthquake can impact on neurodevelopment, specifically the executive function (EF) abilities of children five years following the disaster. The aims of this study were to determine if prenatal earthquake exposure had an effect on EF, to determine how timing of exposure influenced EF, if there were different EF outcomes for boys and girls, and how maternal perceptions of severity influenced the child’s EF. Children from two groups (mothers from Christchurch who experienced the earthquakes and mothers from Dunedin and Timaru who did not) had their EF measured by a self-administered parent questionnaire, the Behaviour Rating Inventory of Executive Function Second Edition (BRIEF 2). Maternal demographics and earthquake severity experiences were gathered through a second self-administered questionnaire. This study found that children who prenatally experienced the earthquake had significantly worse scores on the measures of emotional control and emotional regulation than the standardised average provided by the BRIEF 2. Exposure during the third trimester was associated with the most significant increases in EF compared to children exposed during the second trimester and the standardised average. In addition to emotional control and emotional regulation difficulties, Christchurch boys also exhibited significantly higher scores on the Shift scale. Results also showed that the worse someone close to the mother was injured, the higher the child’s scores on the Inhibit, Organisation, and Emotional Control scale, and the Behaviour Regulation index (BRI) were. Also, children of mothers who reported more significantly injuring themselves in the earthquake had higher Emotional Regulation (ERI) scores. Children whose mothers reported being overall extremely stressed by the earthquake had the largest mean difference in emotional control and ERI scores compared to the standardised average. Despite the small group sizes and continuing aftershocks the variations in trimester and maternal perception of stress indicates that prenatal exposure to a natural disaster does impact EF.
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Negotiating recovery from alcoholism in the context of the Canterbury earthquakes : a thesis submitted to Massey University in fulfilment of the requirements for a Master of Philosophy, Massey University, February 2014
    (Massey University, 2014) Williamson, Kerry J
    This study employs narrative inquiry to document participants’ experiences in relation to maintaining sobriety while living through the Christchurch earthquakes. Eight women and one man were recruited via purposive sampling. Of the 9 participants, 4 were in stable recovery (greater than 5 years), 2 were in sustained recovery (between 1 and 5 years) and 3 were in early recovery (less than 1 year). Qualitative data was gathered using semi-structured, in-depth interviews utilising thematic analysis and incorporating an abductive logic. In the process of recovery from alcohol dependence previous life trauma, environmental conditions, uncertainty about the future and limited resources can be both barriers to recovery from alcoholism and growth opportunities after natural disaster. For some of the participants who contributed to this research, memories of early childhood abuse were recalled and symbolised by the seismic activity during the greater earthquake period. Participants in early recovery or relapsing continued to experience traumatic stress through re-victimisation or trauma re-enactment. Some participants in active addiction identified the earthquakes as both a hindrance and a help with their drinking and self-harming behaviour. For others, a sense of deep personal loss was felt when viewing the devastation of the ruined city which mirrored and reminded them of their life in active addiction. The research findings extend and complement existing theories of ambiguous loss and Post Traumatic Growth (PTG) within the context of addiction and recovery capital. This research also adds to the addiction, domestic violence and disaster literature that is currently available. Narratives of participants in short or long term recovery, suggested that ambiguous loss, and associated grief stemming from both situational and cumulative trauma, surfaced when viewing the earthquake damage. Living through the earthquakes was a time of adaptation and resourcefulness for all but for alcoholics in recovery extra resilience was needed to attend to addiction recovery within the larger picture of daily disaster coping. For all participants post traumatic growth was both an outcome and a process creating a more robust identity at individual levels, post disaster. Findings indicate that trauma can be instrumental in creating alcohol abuse and dependency and that recovery from alcoholism after natural disaster is a complex process requiring personal, community and political interventions.