Efficient milking systems for pastoral dairy farms : a thesis presented to Massey University in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Animal Science at Massey University, Manawatu, New Zealand
Factors affecting milking efficiency in pasture-based dairy systems were explored in
this thesis. An industry survey was conducted on 61 commercial farms with rotary
dairies to benchmark current levels of milking efficiency on-farm. Benchmarks
calculated included; cow throughput (cows milked per hour), milk throughput (kg of
milk harvested per hour), the operator efficiency values of these benchmarks and cluster
utilisation. It was possible to milk more cows per hour in larger rotary dairies, however
operator efficiency peaked at 60 bails.
There was a range of performance within a given rotary size and platform speed
was identified as one of the determining factors. The second experiment modelled the
effect of platform speed and rotary size on throughput using milking duration data
collected during the benchmarking study. Faster platform speeds increased the number
of cows requiring multiple rotations to complete milking, but this did not decrease
A further factor that may affect throughput is individual cow milk yield, and
consequently cow milking duration. An experiment in late lactation was set up to
evaluate strategies to reduce cow milking duration by applying pre-milking stimulation
or manipulating end-of-milking criteria. Pre-milking simulation decreased cow milking
duration but also decreased milking efficiency. Conversely, changing end-of-milking
criteria, by increasing automatic cluster removal (ACR) threshold, reduced cow milking
duration by up to 80 s without compromising milk yield or somatic cell count (SCC).
This was subsequently validated in peak lactation.
In situations without ACR, milking efficiency must not be achieved at the
expense of cow health so an experiment was designed to evaluate the effect of
overmilking on teat-end hyperkeratosis. Clusters remained attached for 0, 2, 5 or 9 min
after milk flow rate dropped below 0.2 kg/min. Teat-end hyperkeratosis was
significantly greater for the 5 and 9 min treatments than 0 and 2 min. The milking
efficiency of herringbone dairies was also benchmarked on 19 commercial farms with
larger dairies achieving greater throughput (in a linear relationship), due to reduced idle
time, but not greater operator efficiency.
Finally, the effect of rotary size, platform speed and end-of-milking criteria were
evaluated in a number of scenarios to maximise operator efficiency. These were used to
calculate the internal rate of return for different rotary sizes.