• Login
    View Item 
    •   Home
    • Massey Documents by Type
    • Theses and Dissertations
    • View Item
    •   Home
    • Massey Documents by Type
    • Theses and Dissertations
    • View Item
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Appraisal : reducing control, enhancing effectiveness : a thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Ph. D. in Education at Massey University, Albany Campus, Auckland, New Zealand

    Icon
    View/Open Full Text
    01_front.pdf (1.115Mb)
    02_whole.pdf (66.37Mb)
    Export to EndNote
    Abstract
    Between 1995 and 1999 the Ministry of Education (MoE) tightened the requirements for appraisal in schools in New Zealand (NZ). The first of three parts of the thesis reports on the impact of this tightening and enhanced control. The results from this impact study showed little indication of outcomes often associated with enhanced control such as increased defensiveness, decreased internal commitment, increased compliance, and inconsistent adoption of initiatives in appraisal. The results demonstrated an overall positive impact on appraisal implementation in schools associated with the enhanced control. On the downside, the results also provided a strong indication that much of the training conducted for appraisal had largely been superficial, and had failed to help appraisers to deal with problems with appraisees. These results led me to clarify 'effectiveness' in appraisal training, and to determine how such training could help appraisers and appraisees to establish educative appraisal interactions. Such interactions lead to effective outcomes in terms of resolving problems, and consequently improved teaching and learning. The theory, philosophy, guiding values and strategies of productive reasoning were refined and adapted to underpin the development of two approaches to training in problem confronting and resolution: one short-term (one day of training fitting national training allocation for approximately 219 appraisers in 25 secondary schools), and one long-term (an action research approach with five appraisers in one school). My implementation of these training interventions, and their evaluation, determined the second and third phases reported on in this thesis. For Intervention #1 (the short-term training), the evaluation results showed a considerable gap between appraiser espousals of educative process implementation and their practice. This became particularly evident when the majority of appraisers reported that the training had helped them to be more open and to deal with, rather than avoid, problems with appraisees, and yet the closer examination of their interactions with appraisees, and appraisee feedback, revealed little employment of an educative process. Intervention #2 (the longer-term training), was designed to enable appraisers to better understand and further internalise the educative process, to provide further opportunities for practice, and provide more extensive follow-up support from myself and other appraisers. Although the intended action research approach, the Problem Resolving Action Research (PRAR) Model, was only partially realised in this intervention, the evaluation results led me to conclude that for three of the five appraisers a considerable positive shift in implementation of educative process skills occurred. These results indicated that the elements contributing to this shift included: appraiser commitment to improvement (for both themselves as appraisers, and for the teachers they were appraising); consciousness-raising associated with exposure of the espousal-practice gap; extended support; and the opportunity to repeat learning. The research also highlighted, and confirmed, the importance in action research of: gaining ownership and commitment; enhancing collaboration, and mutually informing theory and practice. Overall, this thesis provides rare evidence to demonstrate that, given appropriate training, appraisal can ultimately improve teaching and learning.
    Date
    2001
    Author
    Piggot-Irvine, Eileen
    Rights
    The Author
    Publisher
    Massey University
    URI
    http://hdl.handle.net/10179/5579
    Collections
    • Theses and Dissertations
    Metadata
    Show full item record

    Copyright © Massey University
    | Contact Us | Feedback | Copyright Take Down Request | Massey University Privacy Statement
    DSpace software copyright © Duraspace
    v5.7-2020.1-beta1
     

     

    Tweets by @Massey_Research
    Information PagesContent PolicyDepositing content to MROCopyright and Access InformationDeposit LicenseDeposit License SummaryTheses FAQFile FormatsDoctoral Thesis Deposit

    Browse

    All of MROCommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

    My Account

    LoginRegister

    Statistics

    View Usage Statistics

    Copyright © Massey University
    | Contact Us | Feedback | Copyright Take Down Request | Massey University Privacy Statement
    DSpace software copyright © Duraspace
    v5.7-2020.1-beta1