Plantain-mixed pasture collected in different climatic seasons produced less methane and ammonia than ryegrass–white clover pasture in vitro

Context Plantain (PL) is recognised for reducing nitrate leaching and nitrous oxide emissions in pastoral systems. Evidence has shown that cows fed pure PL produced less methane (CH4) than cows fed ryegrass. However, it is unclear if the CH4 reduction can be achieved with PL in mixed pasture. Aim The study evaluated the in vitro rumen fermentation profiles of ryegrass–white clover (RWC) and medium-level PL (PLM, containing ~40% PL) pasture collected during different climatic seasons, to determine whether this inclusion level influences CH4 and rumen ammonia (NH3) production. Methods Substrates were selected from samples with various proportions of PL. Samples were categorised into three climatic seasons (i.e. spring, summer and autumn) and two pasture types (PLM and RWC). Representative samples for these scenarios were tested in an automated in vitro rumen batch culture system for gas, CH4 (mL/g DM) and NH3 (mM/g DM) production. Key results In summer samples, PLM produced approximately 8%, 14% and 19% less CH4 at 12 h, 24 h and potential CH4 production (PCH4), respectively. Although gas production (GP) was similar at 12 and 24 h, PLM had 13% lower potential GP than RWC (P < 0.05). In spring samples, PLM had approximately 11% greater GP and CH4 production at 12 h. For the autumn samples, GP and CH4 production were similar between PLM and RWC (P > 0.05). Net NH3 production from PLM substrates was significantly lower in spring (27%) and autumn (17%) samples, with no differences in summer, despite higher crude protein levels in the selected PLM. Conclusions Compared with RWC, PLM changed rumen fermentation parameters that could translate to potential environmental benefits: PLM produced less net NH3 in spring and autumn samples (27% and 17%, respectively), and up to 19% less CH4 production in summer samples. Implications Incorporating ~40% PL into RWC pasture showed a promising reduction of CH4 emissions and nitrogen losses in vitro. If the in vitro results translate to cows grazing pasture, this could offer greater environmental benefits with minimal input costs. In vitro results suggest that PLM’s potential to mitigate CH4 emissions can be influenced by seasonal variations in pasture quality compared with RWC. However, further animal studies are needed to fully comprehend the CH4 mitigation potential of this forage.

Keywords

forage quality, greenhouse gas, methane mitigation, mixed pasture, nitrogen losses, plant secondary metabolites, Plantago lanceolata, rumen fermentation

Citation

Sivanandarajah K, Donaghy D, Molano G, Horne D, Kemp P, Navarrete S, Ramilan T, Pacheco D. (2025). Plantain-mixed pasture collected in different climatic seasons produced less methane and ammonia than ryegrass–white clover pasture in vitro. Animal Production Science. 65. 10 Collection: Australasian Dairy Science Symposium 2024.

URI

https://mro.massey.ac.nz/handle/10179/73659

Collections

Journal Articles

Full item page